ris3n's Apologetics Codex

Concept

Subjective Experience vs Subjective Reality

subjective reality, subjective experience, is reality subjective, ontological subjectivity, epistemic objectivity, Searle subjectivity, ontological objectivity, epistemic subjectivity, is reality just perception

An etching after Rembrandt's Philosopher in Meditation: an old man sits by a bright window while the rest of the vaulted room and its winding stair fade into shadow

Intro

There are ads on our codex that pay for hosting and keep the codex free. If you can, please consider whitelisting ris3n.com or allowing scripts to support the work.

Sponsored

Brands, events, influencers advertise here

You burn your hand on the stove. The pain is real, and only you feel it. Nobody else can feel your pain for you. That is what people mean by subjective experience: what it is like, from the inside, to be you right now. Seeing red, tasting coffee, feeling joy, feeling afraid. Each one belongs to a someone.

Now someone says, "Reality is subjective." That sounds similar, but it is a much bigger claim. It could mean "everyone sees the world from their own angle," which is true and harmless. Or it could mean "the world itself depends on what people think or feel about it," which is a large and controversial idea. People often slide from the first meaning to the second without noticing.

Here is the key point. Your pain exists only in your experience. Yet the fact that you are in pain is something anyone can know. A doctor can see you flinch, look at the burn and say, truthfully, "She is in pain." Something can be felt by one person and still be a plain fact about the world.

There is a second point. What an experience is about is not automatically real. You can feel real fear of a snake that turns out to be a garden hose. The fear is real. The snake is not.

That matters when someone says, "I feel that my life has meaning, so it does." The feeling is real and worth taking seriously. On its own it does not show that life has a purpose built into reality, any more than fear shows there is a snake. To know that, you need to ask where purpose could come from.

The 30-second version:

Subjective experience is what it feels like to be you: pain, color, joy. Subjective reality is a slippery phrase. It can mean the world seen from your angle, or the much stronger claim that reality depends on minds. Your pain exists only in your experience, yet "she is in pain" is a plain fact anyone can check. And what an experience is about need not be real: real fear, fake snake. So feeling that life has purpose is real, but on its own it does not prove life has an objective purpose. Ask which claim someone is making before you answer it.

Question cheatsheet 7 questions this page answers
  1. What is the difference between subjective experience and subjective reality?
  2. Is reality subjective?
  3. What is ontological subjectivity?
  4. How can something subjective be objectively true?
  5. Can an experience be real and still mislead?
  6. If I feel my life has meaning, does it have meaning?
  7. What question should I ask when someone says reality is subjective?

In full

Subjective experience is the first-person, conscious awareness of a subject: the felt quality of pain, the visual appearance of red, the felt lift of joy. It is subjective in the sense that it exists as experienced by someone and is accessed directly only by that someone. In the philosophy of mind this is the territory of phenomenal consciousness and of the question of what it is like to be a given creature (see Thomas Nagel, and Access and Phenomenal Consciousness).

Subjective reality has no single settled meaning, which is the main thing to know about it. It is used in at least three senses:

  1. Perspectival. Reality as interpreted from a particular standpoint, shaped by a person's location, history, language and concerns. On this reading, "reality is subjective" means only that everyone views a shared world from somewhere.
  2. Constructivist or relativist. Some or all facts (moral, social, aesthetic) are made true by the attitudes of individuals or communities.
  3. Metaphysical idealism. Reality itself is mental or depends for its existence on consciousness. See Idealism.

These are different theses with different burdens of proof. The first is close to a truism. The second and third are substantive philosophical positions. A conversation that uses the phrase without saying which sense is in play will usually equivocate between the harmless first reading and one of the stronger ones.

The clearest tool for untangling this vocabulary is John Searle's distinction between ontological and epistemic senses of "subjective" and "objective," set out in The Construction of Social Reality (1995).

Comparison

Subjective experience Subjective reality
Primary concern What it is like for a subject to undergo a conscious state What reality is, or how it is constituted
Field Philosophy of mind, phenomenology Metaphysics, epistemology, social theory
Needs consciousness? Yes, by definition Depends on the sense: perspectival yes, constructivist in part, idealist yes in the strongest form
Can it be mistaken? The experience itself is undergone, but beliefs about what it shows can be wrong Its claims about the world can be false, like any other thesis
Example The pain of a burned hand; the look of red "Your truth and my truth"; "nothing exists apart from being perceived"
Central question What is it like to be this subject? Does reality depend on minds, and if so, which parts and how?

Subjectivity does not erase objectivity

Searle separates two questions that the single word "subjective" runs together.

  1. Ontological subjectivity and objectivity concern the mode of existence of a thing.
    • Something is ontologically subjective if it exists only as experienced by a subject. Pains, tickles and itches are the standard cases.
    • Something is ontologically objective if it exists independently of any experiencer. Mountains and molecules are the standard cases.
  2. Epistemic subjectivity and objectivity concern the status of a claim.
    • A claim is epistemically objective if its truth can be settled by facts independent of anyone's attitudes or preferences.
    • A claim is epistemically subjective if its truth depends on the attitudes or preferences of the one making it. "This is the best flavor of ice cream" is the usual kind of example.

The two axes cross. Pain is ontologically subjective, since it exists only as felt. Yet the statement "she is in pain" is epistemically objective: it is simply true or false, and a physician, a witness, or the patient's own report can settle it. Searle uses this structure to argue that a scientific study of consciousness is possible: the object is subjective in mode of existence, while claims about it can be objective.

The consequence for debate is direct. "Experience is subjective" is true in the ontological sense. It does not follow that every claim about experience, or about the world experience presents, is subjective in the epistemic sense.

The content of an experience is not automatically a fact

An experience has two sides: the state itself and what it presents. The state can be fully real while what it presents is false.

  • Real fear, unreal danger. A hiker freezes at a coiled shape on the trail. The fear, the pounding heart and the adrenaline are all real. The snake is a length of rope.
  • Real appearance, false content. A straight stick looks bent in water. The visual appearance is real; the bend is not.
  • Real conviction, wrong conclusion. A person feels certain he locked the door and is mistaken.

So the reality of an experience establishes that the experience occurred. Whether the world is as the experience presents it is a further question, settled by other means. Scripture makes the same point about the human heart:

The heart is deceitful above all things, and it is exceedingly corrupt: who can know it? (Jeremiah 17:9, ASV)

This cuts in both directions. It warns the Christian against treating feeling as proof, and it warns the skeptic against treating his own felt sense that life is meaningless, or meaningful, as the last word.

Applied to purpose and meaning

The commonest use of this confusion in conversations about God concerns purpose. "I experience my life as meaningful, so it has meaning, and I need no God for that." The experience reported is real and should be honored. The question is what it shows.

The argument in brief:

  1. Experiencing something as having a property does not, by itself, establish that the property exists independently of the experience.
  2. Experiencing one's life as purposeful is experiencing it as having a property.
  3. Therefore experiencing one's life as purposeful does not, by itself, establish that it has an objective purpose.

The argument grants that felt purpose is real and that people find genuine meaning in love, work and service. Its claim is narrower: the experience alone cannot carry the weight of the stronger claim. Whether life has a purpose that holds regardless of how anyone feels depends on what reality is like: whether there is a mind whose intention gives things an end. That is the question taken up in The Original Intention Argument and the Argument from Purpose Meaning and Hope.

The same structure answers "I create my own meaning" (see I Create My Own Meaning Objection Defeater) and "morality is subjective" (see Subjective Morality Defeater). In each case the felt or chosen quality is real and ontologically subjective. The live question is whether anything epistemically objective stands behind it.

Scripture names the longing directly:

He hath made everything beautiful in its time: also he hath set eternity in their heart, yet so that man cannot find out the work that God hath done from the beginning even to the end. (Ecclesiastes 3:11, ASV)

On the Christian reading, the felt pull toward lasting meaning is real and points beyond itself. The apologist's work is to show that the pointing has a target, which the feeling alone cannot do. See Ecclesiastes 3.11.

Apologetic use

Define the term before answering it

When someone says "reality is subjective," the first move is to ask which claim is being made. The answers lead to three different conversations.

  1. Ordinary first-person experience. "I experience the world from my own point of view." Agree at once. Christianity has no quarrel with it.
  2. Perspectivism. "No one has a view from nowhere; all knowledge is shaped by perspective." Grant the observation, then ask whether perspectives can be more or less accurate. If they can, there is a reality they are accurate to. If they cannot, the claim "all knowledge is perspectival" has no more standing than its denial. See Self-refutation.
  3. Metaphysical idealism or global relativism. "Reality itself depends on minds" or "truth is whatever is true for you." This is a substantive thesis and carries a burden of proof. A Christian may note that classical theism holds a form of mind-first reality, in that the world depends on the mind of God, while denying that it depends on human minds.

Cross-examination

  1. "Are you claiming reality itself is subjective, or that your experience of an independent reality is subjective?"
  2. "Is your pain ontologically subjective? Is it still objectively true that you are in pain?"
  3. "Have you ever had a real feeling about something that turned out not to be real? What did that show you about feelings as evidence?"
  4. "When you say your life has meaning, do you mean you experience it that way, or that it would have meaning even if you stopped feeling it?"
  5. "If the second, what in reality makes that true?"

The first question does most of the work. It separates metaphysical idealism, perspectivism and ordinary first-person experience, and most people, once asked, mean the third. The remaining questions show that the subjective character of an experience leaves open the objective questions the conversation is really about, including purpose, which The Original Intention Argument addresses directly.

What to grant

  • Experience is real and is evidence of something. Christian epistemology takes experience seriously, including religious experience.
  • Everyone sees from a perspective. Humility about one's own vantage point is a virtue, and Scripture commends it.
  • The meaning people feel in their lives is real as experience. The question is only whether it is grounded.

Scholarship

Published academic works this page draws on, each matched to a publisher, index or library catalog record.

  • John R. Searle, The construction of social reality (Free Press, 1995). Open Library

See also

Common questions this page answers

Q: What is the difference between subjective experience and subjective reality?

Subjective experience is a conscious subject's first-person awareness, such as feeling pain or seeing red. Subjective reality is an ambiguous phrase that can mean the world as seen from a perspective, the view that some facts depend on people's attitudes, or the strong claim that reality itself depends on consciousness. The first is a fact about minds; the second is a thesis about the world.

Q: Is reality subjective?

It depends what is meant. Everyone experiences reality from a perspective, which is true. Whether reality itself depends on human minds is a separate, controversial claim that needs its own argument. The fact that experience is subjective does not by itself show that the world experience presents is.

Q: What is ontological subjectivity?

In John Searle's terms, something is ontologically subjective when it exists only as experienced by a subject, as pain does. Something is ontologically objective when it exists independently of any experiencer, as a mountain does.

Q: How can something subjective be objectively true?

Searle separates the mode of existence of a thing from the status of claims about it. Pain is ontologically subjective, since it exists only as felt, yet "she is in pain" is epistemically objective, because it is true or false regardless of anyone's preferences and can be checked. A subjective experience can be the subject of an objective fact.

Q: Can an experience be real and still mislead?

Yes. The experience can be fully real while what it presents is false. Real fear of a rope mistaken for a snake, a stick that looks bent in water, and a confident memory that turns out wrong are all examples. An experience shows that it occurred; whether the world is as it seems is a further question.

Q: If I feel my life has meaning, does it have meaning?

The feeling is real and worth taking seriously. But experiencing something as having a property does not by itself establish that the property exists independently of the experience. Whether life has an objective purpose depends on whether reality contains a source of purpose, such as an intending mind, and that question needs to be argued separately.

Q: What question should I ask when someone says reality is subjective?

Ask: "Are you claiming reality itself is subjective, or that your experience of an independent reality is subjective?" The answer separates metaphysical idealism, perspectivism and ordinary first-person experience. Most people mean the last, which no one disputes.

Hear the whole codex

Every page and every section, read aloud.

Everything VIP includes:

    "Study to shew thyself approved unto God." 2 Timothy 2:15

    See VIP plans, from $2.15 a month