Concept

James Fulton Engstrom (Fulton Sheen 2010)

Intro

On 16 September 2010 Bonnie Engstrom gave birth at home in Goodfield, Illinois. The baby, James, came out limp. A tight knot in his umbilical cord had cut off his blood and oxygen. He had no pulse and was not breathing.

People at the house started CPR. An ambulance took him to OSF Saint Francis Medical Center in Peoria, where the staff kept working on him and gave him two doses of adrenaline. Nothing worked. His parents had been praying for the help of Fulton Sheen, the Illinois-born archbishop famous for his television programs in the 1950s. An emergency doctor said they would try for five more minutes and then stop. Then, 61 minutes after birth, James's heart started beating and did not stop again.

The Diocese of Peoria investigated the case, and the Vatican's medical experts found no natural explanation for his survival. Pope Francis approved it as a miracle in 2019. It is the miracle by which Sheen was beatified in St. Louis on 24 September 2026, with James and his family taking part. The case is filed in the documented tier because it passed the formal Vatican process.

Fulton J. Sheen on the set of his television program, 1952. Photo: Fred Palumbo, New York World-Telegram and Sun Collection, Library of Congress; public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The 30-second version:

James Fulton Engstrom was born at home in Illinois on 16 September 2010 with a true knot in his umbilical cord, and he had no pulse and no breath. CPR began at once and continued at a Peoria hospital, where two doses of epinephrine failed and the staff were about to stop. His parents were praying to Fulton Sheen. At 61 minutes his heart started at 148 beats a minute and kept going. A Vatican panel of medical experts found no natural explanation for the survival of a child delivered stillborn, and he was reported to be developing normally at age three. Pope Francis approved the miracle in July 2019, and Sheen was beatified in 2026.

◎ See this page's graph and discover linked topics →

In full

Fulton John Sheen (1895 to 1979), born in El Paso, Illinois, was a Catholic bishop and broadcaster whose radio and television programs, above all Life Is Worth Living (1952 to 1957), reached millions. The Diocese of Peoria, where he was ordained, opened his cause, and the Engstrom case became its miracle. According to The Catholic Post, the diocesan newspaper of Peoria, James Fulton Engstrom was delivered during a planned home birth in Goodfield on 16 September 2010; a true knot in the umbilical cord had tightened during delivery and cut off blood and oxygen. Bystanders gave CPR for about twenty minutes while waiting for an ambulance; at OSF Saint Francis Medical Center he was classed as pulseless electrical activity, and two doses of epinephrine had no effect. An emergency physician proposed five more minutes before stopping. At 61 minutes his heart began at 148 beats a minute and did not falter. The Diocese of Peoria opened its inquiry in September 2011 and heard family members, first responders, doctors and nurses; the acts went to the Congregation for the Causes of Saints in December 2011. In March 2014 the Archbishop Fulton Sheen Foundation announced that a seven-member Vatican medical panel had found "no natural explanation for the survival of a child delivered stillborn," and that James, then three, was developing normally. The theologians and the cardinals and bishops of the Congregation concurred, and the Holy See Press Office bulletin of 6 July 2019 records the decree, approved by Pope Francis on 5 July, on the miracle attributed to the intercession of the Venerable Fulton Sheen. A beatification set for 21 December 2019 in Peoria was postponed weeks beforehand; the Vatican cleared the cause in February 2026, and Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle beatified Sheen in St. Louis on 24 September 2026, with James Fulton Engstrom and his family in the procession. Under the Miracles schema the case is Tier 1 on Vatican ratification.

Summary

James Fulton Engstrom was born without a pulse or breath at a planned home birth in Goodfield, Illinois, on 16 September 2010, after a true knot in his umbilical cord cut off his blood and oxygen. CPR, transport to OSF Saint Francis Medical Center in Peoria and two doses of epinephrine failed to restart his heart; at 61 minutes, as staff prepared to stop, it began beating at 148 a minute. His parents, Travis and Bonnie Engstrom, had prayed for the intercession of Fulton Sheen. The Diocese of Peoria investigated from 2011, a Vatican medical panel found no natural explanation (announced March 2014), and Pope Francis approved the miracle on 5 July 2019. Sheen was beatified in St. Louis on 24 September 2026.

The event

1. The birth. On 16 September 2010 Bonnie Engstrom delivered James at home in Goodfield, Illinois. A true knot in the umbilical cord had tightened during delivery, cutting off blood flow and oxygen. His mother said his arms "flopped by his side" when she reached for him (The Catholic Post, 2014).
2. CPR at home. He had no pulse and was not breathing. Those present gave chest compressions and CPR for about twenty minutes while waiting for an ambulance (The Catholic Post, 2014).
3. At the hospital. At OSF Saint Francis Medical Center in Peoria he was classed as pulseless electrical activity. Two doses of epinephrine had no effect (The Catholic Post, 2014; 2019).
4. The prayer. His parents immediately invoked the prayers of Fulton Sheen (The Catholic Post, 2019).
5. Five more minutes. An emergency physician said they would try for five more minutes and then call it. The Catholic Post notes that the doctor would have stopped sooner had he known how long efforts had already lasted.
6. The heartbeat. At 61 minutes after birth James's heart started at 148 beats a minute and never faltered (The Catholic Post, 2014).
7. Afterward. In March 2014 the Sheen Foundation reported that James, then three, was developing normally. His mother credits God with restarting his heart and healing his brain and other organs (The Catholic Post, 2019).
8. Recognition. Diocesan inquiry opened September 2011; acts sent to Rome December 2011; Vatican medical panel finding announced 6 March 2014; decree approved 5 July 2019 and published 6 July 2019; beatification in St. Louis, 24 September 2026.

Witnesses + documentation

• Travis and Bonnie Engstrom, his parents, who testified to the diocesan tribunal and have spoken publicly.
• First responders, doctors and nurses who treated him, heard as witnesses by the diocesan tribunal; each told it there was no medical explanation for his recovery (The Catholic Post, 2019).
• Bishop Daniel R. Jenky, CSC, of Peoria, who opened the diocesan inquiry.
• The Archbishop Fulton Sheen Foundation, which announced the medical panel's finding in March 2014.
• The Congregation for the Causes of Saints, whose medical consultors, theologians and cardinals reviewed the case, and whose decree is recorded in the Holy See Press Office bulletin of 6 July 2019.

Verification

What was checked:

1. The official recognition. The Holy See Press Office bulletin of 6 July 2019 lists the decree on the miracle attributed to the Venerable Fulton Sheen, born 8 May 1895 in El Paso, Illinois. The bulletin does not name the patient; the identification comes from the Diocese of Peoria and its newspaper.
2. The medical finding. The March 2014 announcement reports a seven-member medical panel and quotes its conclusion.
3. The outcome. The beatification took place on 24 September 2026, and James Fulton Engstrom, then sixteen, took part in the procession.

Naturalistic explanations considered:

• Late return of circulation in newborns. Newborns are sometimes resuscitated after long efforts, and survival after prolonged CPR is reported in the medical literature. The case does not rest on survival alone, but on survival without the brain and organ damage that an hour without circulation is expected to cause.
• A shorter interval than reported. If the heart had been beating faintly and undetected, the interval would be shorter. Against it, the hospital classed him as pulseless electrical activity, and the 61 minutes is the figure the tribunal and the medical panel worked from.
• Effective CPR. Continuous compressions supply some circulation, which helps explain survival. It does not by itself explain a normal outcome after more than an hour.

Caveats and remaining uncertainties:

• The medical file is not public. No published source prints the hospital records or the report of the Vatican medical panel, and no treating physician is named in the reports found.
• The account comes mainly through Catholic sources. The fullest narratives are from the Diocese of Peoria's newspaper and the Sheen Foundation, though the case was also reported by the Associated Press and national outlets.
• The 2019 postponement concerned Sheen's record as a bishop, not the miracle. It does not bear on the medical facts.
• No skeptical analysis was found. A search turned up no published critique of this case.

Apologetic value

• A sharp before and after. No pulse for 61 minutes, then a strong heartbeat and normal development. The question it presses is not whether he survived but how he survived intact.
• Many professional witnesses. First responders, doctors and nurses testified under a formal inquiry, which answers the objection that the account rests on the parents' memory alone.
• Answered prayer, read in biblical terms. "The supplication of a righteous man availeth much in its working" (James 5:16, ASV). The healing is God's; the recognition attributes it to Sheen's intercession, which Protestant readers will read differently.
• Honest limits. The records are not public, and long resuscitations sometimes succeed. Deploy it as one strand in a cumulative case. See Argument from Miracles.
• How to deploy it. Lead with the knot, the hour without a pulse and the doctor's five more minutes, concede that prolonged resuscitation sometimes works, and press the normal outcome.

See also

• Miracles, master hub
• _schema, the vetting standard this entry follows
• John Smith Ice Drowning (Lake Saint Louis 2015), another revival after a long time without a pulse, also in the St. Louis area
• Yaxury Solorzano (Jose Gregorio Hernandez 2017), another recent beatification miracle with a named medical team
• Argument from Miracles, the argument this case supports
• David Hume, whose standard for credible miracle testimony this case presses on
• Naturalism, the worldview such cases press against