ris3n's Apologetics Codex

Concept

Delores Winder (Dallas 1975)

Delores Winder healing, Delores Winder Kathryn Kuhlman, Surprised by Healing, Woman healed in a body cast at a Kuhlman meeting, Casdorph The Miracles Winder

Memorial marker for Kathryn Kuhlman at her birthplace, Concordia, Missouri, erected 1976 (photo by PrimerFender, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons)

Intro

There are ads on our codex that pay for hosting and keep the codex free. If you can, please consider whitelisting ris3n.com or allowing scripts to support the work.

Sponsored

Brands, events, influencers advertise here

Delores Winder had weak bones from childhood. As an adult her spine began to collapse. Surgeons fused her vertebrae, the fusion failed, and they tried again, four times in all. To control the pain, doctors also cut nerve pathways in her spinal cord, an operation called a cordotomy, which left her lower body numb. For about fourteen years she lived in a body cast and a neck brace. By 1975 she was told she was dying.

She was a churchgoer who did not believe God still heals. On 30 August 1975 a friend persuaded her to attend a Methodist conference on the Holy Spirit in Dallas, where the healing evangelist Kathryn Kuhlman was speaking. During the meeting she felt burning in her legs, the first feeling there in years. She was helped to the stage, and by her account she walked off it without her cast, her cane or anyone's help.

A year later a physician and medical researcher, Dr H. Richard Casdorph, published her case in a book about ten healings he had examined through medical records and X-rays. Because the case rests on one physician's review and on Winder's own testimony, it sits in the third tier of this collection.

The 30-second version: A woman with four failed spinal fusions, a cordotomy and fourteen years in a body cast went to a Holy Spirit conference in Dallas in 1975, felt sensation return to her legs during prayer, and walked out of the meeting without her cast. A physician reviewed her records and included her case in a 1976 book. The case is well known and consistently told, but the medical records themselves have never been published in full.

In full

Delores Winder's healing is reported in two published sources. The first is H. Richard Casdorph, MD, The Miracles: A Medical Doctor Says Yes to Miracles! (Plainfield, N.J.: Logos International, 1976), in which Casdorph, a physician and medical researcher, presents ten healings associated with Kathryn Kuhlman's ministry after reviewing case histories, X-rays and medical reports and, by the account of later summaries, submitting them to specialists. A summary of Casdorph's findings states that he held Winder's medical records "an inch thick," documenting seven serious spinal procedures, and that her doctor accepted she had "gotten an excellent result physically." The second source is Winder's own account, Surprised by Healing, written with Bill Keith (Destiny Image, 2009 in electronic form; paperback 2013), whose publisher dates the healing to 30 August 1975 at "a Methodist Conference on the Holy Spirit" in Dallas, Texas, where Kuhlman was speaking, and describes her as "terminally ill with pseudo-arthrosis and having been in a body cast for over fourteen years." She later told the story on Sid Roth's radio and television programmes. The case meets the Tier 3 standard: a named patient, a specific date and place, and a physician's attestation published within a year. It falls short of Tier 2 because the treating surgeons are not named in any source read for this entry, no contemporaneous press report has been located, and Casdorph's chapter itself could not be checked.

Summary

Delores Winder, a woman with a lifelong bone disorder, four failed spinal fusions, cordotomy surgery and about fourteen years in a body cast, reported immediate healing at a Methodist conference on the Holy Spirit in Dallas on 30 August 1975, at which Kathryn Kuhlman was speaking. Dr H. Richard Casdorph reviewed her records and published the case in The Miracles (1976). Winder later recounted it in Surprised by Healing with Bill Keith, and she lived and ministered for decades afterward in Shreveport, Louisiana.

The event

A fragile skeleton. In the account summarised from her radio interview with Sid Roth, Winder had from childhood a rare condition in which her bones did not absorb calcium and other minerals, so that they broke easily. No source read for this entry names the disease.

The failed fusions. In her late twenties several vertebrae collapsed and she had a spinal fusion, which joins vertebrae so that they heal as one bone. It failed and was repeated three more times. A fusion that fails to knit is called a pseudarthrosis, literally a "false joint," and the publisher's description of her book gives that as her diagnosis.

Cordotomy. To relieve pain that the fusions had not cured, doctors performed a percutaneous cordotomy, which destroys the pain-carrying pathways in the spinal cord. One summary of Casdorph's book says she had two. The result was loss of feeling in her lower body.

Waiting to die. She wore a full body cast with a neck brace for about fourteen years. By her account, at forty-eight she weighed seventy-three pounds and had been sent home to die. Doctors suggested she might extend her life by staying still in bed, which she refused to do.

The conference. On 30 August 1975 she attended a Methodist conference on the Holy Spirit at which Kathryn Kuhlman spoke. She did not believe in divine healing and went reluctantly. During the service she felt a burning sensation in her legs. She was helped to the platform, felt the floor beneath her feet, and found she could bend. In her words, "I walked off that platform - no cast, no cane, no assistance."

Afterward. She arrived home in the early hours of the morning. The next day, by her account, she showered by herself and ate a normal meal. Her doctor later confirmed the change. She spent the following decades speaking about the healing and ministering from her home in Shreveport, Louisiana.

Witnesses + documentation

  • Delores Winder, whose account is given in Surprised by Healing (with Bill Keith) and in interviews with Sid Roth on radio and on the television programme It's Supernatural!
  • Her family, her husband Bill and her son Chris, fourteen at the time, who are named in her account and present in it as witnesses to her condition before and after.
  • H. Richard Casdorph, MD, who reviewed her medical records and published the case in The Miracles (Logos International, 1976), a book of ten cases that includes some of the X-rays.
  • Her treating physician, quoted in a summary of Casdorph's account as accepting that she had "gotten an excellent result physically." The physician is not named in any source read for this entry.

Verification

  1. The book exists and is datable. The Miracles by H. Richard Casdorph was published by Logos International of Plainfield, New Jersey, in 1976 (ISBN 088270172X), within a year of the healing. Its catalogue record at the Internet Archive confirms title, author, publisher and date.
  2. The date and setting are stated by the publisher of her account. The publisher's description of Surprised by Healing gives 30 August 1975, a Methodist conference on the Holy Spirit, Dallas, and Kathryn Kuhlman as speaker.
  3. A physician reviewed records. Summaries of Casdorph's book state that he examined her case history, operative history and X-rays, and that her records documented seven serious spinal procedures.
  4. She lived on for decades. A 2008 account of her radio interview describes her as eighty years old and ministering in Shreveport, more than thirty years after she had been sent home to die.

Naturalistic explanations considered:

  • Emotional excitement and suggestion. Large healing meetings produce strong emotion, and people sometimes move beyond their usual limits for a short time. Excitement does not knit a failed spinal fusion, and Winder's account describes a lasting change: a woman who had been bedridden in a cast showering and eating normally the next day and living for decades afterward.
  • Recovering sensation after cordotomy. Pain relief from cordotomy is known to fade in some patients over time, so a skeptic could argue that regained feeling in her legs reflected nerve recovery. That explanation would not account for the reported return of spinal stability, which is why the case depends on before-and-after imaging. Casdorph's book is said to include X-rays, but they were not examined for this entry.
  • Misdiagnosis or exaggeration. A skeptic may suspect that the earlier condition was less severe than reported. Seven spinal procedures, if the records are as Casdorph described them, make that hard to sustain.

Caveats and remaining uncertainties:

  • The key document was not read. Casdorph's chapter is the only physician's review, and the book is restricted to borrowing online. This entry relies on the publisher's description of Winder's book, on Winder's interviews, and on secondary summaries of Casdorph.
  • No named surgeons or hospitals. None of the sources read names her surgeons, her hospitals or her treating physician.
  • No contemporaneous press report. No newspaper report from 1975 describing her healing has been located.
  • The Kuhlman question. In Healing: A Doctor in Search of a Miracle (Random House, 1974), surgeon William A. Nolen followed up people who claimed healing at a Kuhlman service and found no case he would call a miracle. His book appeared a year before Winder's healing and does not address her case, and Nolen himself did not regard Kuhlman as consciously dishonest. No skeptical investigator is known to have addressed Winder by name.

Tensions

The sources agree on the main outline and differ on details:

  • The operations. "Four spinal fusions and two cordotomies" in one summary of Casdorph; "seven serious spinal procedures" in the same summary; four fusions and one percutaneous cordotomy in Winder's radio account.
  • The diagnosis. "Pseudo-arthrosis" in the publisher's description; a childhood bone-mineral disorder in her radio account; "severe spinal problems" in the Casdorph summary. The first describes the failed fusions and the second the underlying weakness, so the two may both be correct.
  • The length of illness. "Over fourteen years" in a body cast (publisher); fourteen years (Casdorph summary); about fifteen years in that condition (radio account).
  • The venue. "In Dallas, Texas" (publisher); "a nearby town" (radio account). No source names the building.
  • The book's date. The publisher lists Surprised by Healing in 2009 and booksellers list a 2013 paperback, which appear to be two editions.

Apologetic value

  • A Protestant healing with a physician's review. The collection's documented cases come mostly from Catholic bodies such as the Lourdes Medical Bureau. Winder's case comes from a Methodist setting and a charismatic evangelist, and it was reviewed by a physician within a year.
  • A skeptical beneficiary. Winder went to the meeting doubting that God heals and went reluctantly. The case does not fit the picture of a believer whose expectation produced her recovery.
  • The Gospel pattern. The paralysed man let down through the roof "arose, and straightway took up the bed, and went forth before them all" (Mark 2:12, ASV), and the lame man at the temple gate "leaping up, he stood, and began to walk" (Acts 3:8, ASV). Winder's account follows the same shape: a person unable to walk, instant movement, public witness.
  • How to deploy it. Use it as an illustration, and say plainly that it is a third-tier case: the date, place and physician's book are verifiable, and the medical records are not public. For load-bearing cases use the Tier 1 and Tier 2 entries, such as Barbara Cummiskey Snyder (Wheaton 1981), whose physicians are named.

Scholarship

Published academic works this page draws on, each matched to a publisher, index or library catalog record.

  • William A. Nolen, Healing: a doctor in search of a miracle (Random House, 1975). Open Library
  • Delores Winder and Bill Keith, Surprised by Healing (2009). Open Library

See also

Common questions this page answers

Q: Who was Delores Winder?

Delores Winder was a woman with a lifelong bone disorder who had four failed spinal fusions, cordotomy surgery and about fourteen years in a body cast. She reported being healed at a Methodist conference on the Holy Spirit in Dallas on 30 August 1975, where Kathryn Kuhlman was speaking, and spent decades afterward telling the story from her home in Shreveport, Louisiana.

Q: Did a doctor ever examine the Delores Winder healing?

Yes. Dr H. Richard Casdorph reviewed her medical records and included her among ten cases in his 1976 book The Miracles. A summary of his account says her records were "an inch thick" and documented seven serious spinal procedures. The records have not been published in full, and her treating surgeons are not named in the sources available.

Q: Were Kathryn Kuhlman's healings ever investigated by skeptics?

Surgeon William Nolen followed up people who claimed healing at a Kuhlman service and reported in 1974 that he found none he would call a miracle. His study appeared a year before Winder's healing and did not include her case, and no skeptic is known to have examined her case by name.

Q: How strong is the evidence for the Delores Winder healing?

It is a third-tier case in this collection. The date, place and physician's book are verifiable, and the account has stayed consistent for decades. The medical records, imaging and treating doctors are not publicly available, and the sources differ on some details, so the case illustrates the pattern of modern healing reports without carrying the weight of a peer-reviewed or bureau-ratified case.

Hear the whole codex

Every page and every section, read aloud.

Everything VIP includes:

  • Every page and section read aloud
  • Playlists: up to 20, with 25 pages or sections each
  • The Debate prep kit: a 10 to 20 minute cram drill on any argument
  • Listening counts toward ris3n leaders
  • The gold VIP mark beside your name on ris3n leaders
  • No ads, with VIP+ (annual) or Founder (arrives at launch)

"Study to shew thyself approved unto God." 2 Timothy 2:15

See VIP plans, from $2.15 a month