Concept
Can I Love Someone While Disagreeing With Their Choices
can I love someone while disagreeing with their choices, how to love someone you disagree with, does loving someone mean approving of everything, how do christians love people whose choices they disagree with, love the sinner hate the sinIntro
Maybe it is your son, your sister, your best friend or your coworker. You love them, and you disagree with a choice they made, and you are afraid that saying so will cost you the relationship. Jesus lived this tension every day. He loved people fully, ate at their tables, told them the truth, and never stopped going after them.
See this page's graph and discover linked topics
In full
The question asks whether love and moral disagreement can live in the same relationship, or whether loving someone requires approving of everything they do. The primary text is Mark 12:28-34, where Jesus names love for God and love for neighbor as the two greatest commandments, with neighbor-love measured "as yourself." Three Gospel scenes show what that looked like in practice: Jesus asking a Samaritan woman for a drink and then speaking honestly about her life (John 4), the father running to his returning son in the parable Jesus told to critics who resented His table fellowship (Luke 15), and the woman brought to Him for stoning (John 8:1-11), a passage whose place in John's Gospel is textually uncertain and is treated fairly below. The page argues that biblical love seeks a person's whole good, which leaves room for honest disagreement offered with humility and staying power. Christians differ on how that works out in practice, for instance whether attending a particular ceremony signals approval, and those decisions call for conscience, counsel and prayer rather than a single rule.
The struggle
You go quiet at family dinners because one wrong word could start a fight. You feel pulled between two fears: that if you say nothing, you are betraying what you believe, and that if you say anything, you will lose someone you love. Maybe you already said too much once, in the wrong way, and the distance has not closed. Maybe they have told you that if you really loved them, you would agree.
What Jesus said
Jesus answered, The greatest is, 'Hear, Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one: you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind, and with all your strength.' This is the first commandment. The second is like this, 'You shall love your neighbor as yourself.' There is no other commandment greater than these. (Mark 12:29-31, WEB)
Love for God comes first, and love for neighbor comes right beside it. Jesus gives no exception for neighbors we disagree with.
The setting
In Mark 12 Jesus is in the temple courts during His last week, facing a series of hostile questions. One scribe asks a sincere one: which commandment is greatest? Jesus answers from Deuteronomy 6:4-5 and Leviticus 19:18, and the scribe agrees warmly. Jesus tells him, "You are not far from God's Kingdom" (Mark 12:34). Even with a religious leader from a group that mostly opposed Him, Jesus finds common ground and speaks kindly.
In John 4, Jesus asks a Samaritan woman for water. Jews and Samaritans avoided each other, and she is surprised that He speaks to her at all (John 4:9). He offers her living water, and He also names the truth about her five husbands without contempt. She runs to tell her town about Him.
In Luke 15, the religious leaders complain, "This man welcomes sinners, and eats with them" (Luke 15:2). Jesus answers with three stories of lost things found. In the third, the father sees his son far off, "was moved with compassion, and ran, and fell on his neck, and kissed him" (Luke 15:20). The father never approved of the son's choices, and he never stopped watching the road.

The Return of the Prodigal Son by Rembrandt, about 1668, State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg. The father in Jesus' parable (Luke 15:11-32) holds his son close without having approved the road that brought him home. Public domain (Wikimedia Commons), resized.
John 8:1-11 tells of a woman brought to Jesus to be stoned. He says, "He who is without sin among you, let him throw the first stone at her" (John 8:7), and after the accusers leave:
Jesus, standing up, saw her and said, Woman, where are your accusers? Did no one condemn you? She said, No one, Lord. Jesus said, Neither do I condemn you. Go your way. From now on, sin no more. (John 8:10-11, WEB)
This passage is missing from the earliest manuscripts of John and appears in different places in later ones, so most scholars hold that it was not part of John's original Gospel. Many also think it preserves a genuine early memory of Jesus. Christians read it with both facts in view, and nothing in this page depends on it alone; see Woman Caught in Adultery Was Added Objection Defeater.
What this means today
This section is application, drawn from the texts above.
- Love seeks the whole good of the person. "As yourself" (Mark 12:31) means wanting for them what you want for yourself: life, truth, and nearness to God. Approval and love are different things, and Jesus gave love to people whose choices He did not endorse (Luke 15:2).
- Presence earns the right to speak. Jesus asked the Samaritan woman for a drink before He spoke about her life (John 4:7). Most people hear hard truth only from someone who has shown up for them. Eat together, help them, remember their birthday.
- Truth comes with humility. Jesus sent the accusers away by reminding them of their own sin (John 8:7). Before you speak to someone else's choices, take an honest look at your own (Matthew 7:3-5).
Common misunderstandings
- "If you loved me, you would agree with me." Agreement and love are separate. Parents, friends and spouses disagree with people they love every day. Jesus loved the rich young man and still told him what he lacked (Mark 10:21).
- "Love the sinner, hate the sin" settles everything. The phrase points at something true, but it can sound cold, and some people hear only the second half. Show the love first, in actions they can see, and speak about choices rarely, gently and when invited.
- The hard objection: "Christians just use 'love' as a cover for judgment." Sometimes that is true, and it should be confessed. The answer is to love the way Jesus did: generous time, real friendship, no contempt, and room for the other person to disagree with you too.
Love never requires staying in danger. If someone's choices put you or others at risk, through abuse, violence or addiction, safety comes first. Get help from a pastor, counselor or the authorities, and you can keep loving from a safe distance.
Put it into practice
- Today, do one kind thing for the person you disagree with that has nothing to do with the disagreement.
- This week, ask them a real question about their life and listen without steering toward your view.
- Talk with a pastor or wise friend before you raise a hard subject, and pray together about timing and words.
- If you spoke harshly in the past, apologize for the way you said it, even if you still hold the view.
A prayer for today
Father, You love me while I am still far from perfect. Help me love this person the way You love me. Give me patience to listen, courage to be honest, and the grace to stay. Guard my mouth from pride and my heart from bitterness. Draw both of us closer to You. In Jesus' name, amen.
Reflect and respond
- Who comes to mind when you read this question, and what do you most want for them?
- Have your words or silence toward them come more from love or from fear?
- What is one way you can show up for them this week without talking about the disagreement?
Talk it over
Many readers love someone whose choices they cannot agree with. Share in the discussion below what has helped you stay close, or where you are still stuck.
See also
- Life's Hard Questions, the full series
- How Do I Love Someone Who Deliberately Hurt Me, when the other person's choices have wounded you
- Why Trust Christianity When Christians Are Hypocrites, on the judgment people fear from believers
- Biblical Love, what Scripture means by love
- agapē, the Greek word for self-giving love
- God's Love for Creation, how God loves those who resist Him
- Woman Caught in Adultery Was Added Objection Defeater, the textual history of John 8:1-11
- Mark 12.28-34, the passage at the center of this page
- Luke 15.11-32, the father who never stopped watching the road
Common questions this page answers
Q: Can I love someone and still disagree with their choices?
Yes. Jesus loved people whose choices He did not endorse, ate with them and spoke honestly to them (Luke 15:1-2, John 4). Love seeks a person's whole good, and that leaves room for honest disagreement.
Q: Does loving someone mean I have to approve of everything they do?
No. Jesus' command to love your neighbor as yourself (Mark 12:31) means wanting their true good. Parents and friends disagree with people they love all the time, and the relationship can stay strong.
Q: Is the story of the woman caught in adultery in the original Bible?
Most scholars hold that John 7:53-8:11 was not part of John's original Gospel, since the earliest manuscripts lack it, though many think it preserves an authentic early memory of Jesus. No Christian teaching depends on it alone.
Q: How do I talk to a family member about a choice I disagree with?
Build the relationship first, pray and seek counsel about timing, speak once, gently and humbly, and then keep loving them whether or not they agree.
Q: Should a Christian attend a wedding or event they disagree with?
Christians come to different conclusions on this, and Scripture does not give a single rule for every case. Pray, talk with your pastor, and act with a clear conscience and a loving tone either way.