# Good and Evil Are Equal Opposites Objection Defeater

<!-- type: argument | created: 2026-11-14 | updated: 2026-11-14 -->

## Intro

You will often hear it said as if it settles something: *"Good is just the opposite of evil. You can't have one without the other."* Sometimes it comes with an image, light and dark, yin and yang, two sides of one coin. Sometimes it is aimed at Christianity directly: if good needs evil, then a perfectly good God would need evil too, and the Christian picture of a good God with no rival falls apart.

The claim sounds deep, but it runs together two different ideas. Two words can be opposites in meaning without both naming real things. Darkness is the opposite of light, yet there is no such stuff as darkness. Light is real energy, and darkness is what we call a place where that energy is missing. Silence is the lack of sound. Blindness is the lack of sight in an eye that should see. Sickness is health gone wrong.

Good and evil belong in that group. Every evil needs some good to feed on. A lie needs the gift of speech, cruelty needs a living person with strength and a will, and murder is evil because life is good. But good needs no evil at all. A person can be healthy who was never sick, and someone can tell the truth in a world where nobody ever lied. This is the classic Christian teaching, worked out by Augustine and Aquinas: evil is real, the way a hole or a wound is real, but it lives off the good it spoils.

![An etching after Rembrandt's Philosopher in Meditation: an old man sits by a bright window while the rest of the vaulted room and its winding stair fade into shadow](/codex/assets/longhi-after-rembrandt-philosopher-in-contemplation.jpg)

_Giuseppe Longhi, etching after Rembrandt's *Philosopher in Meditation* (1632). The light comes through the window and the dark is simply where it does not reach: two opposites, one reality. Science History Institute. Image: public domain, via [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Le_Philosophe_en_Contemplation_(The_Philosopher_in_Contemplation)_-_DPLA_-_d514c9acafd7d33643648868356aa40d.jpg)._

The saying "you need evil to know good" mixes up how we notice something with what makes it exist. Contrast can help us notice health, but health does not need disease in order to be real.

There is a turn at the end, too. Anyone who calls something evil is measuring it against a good it falls short of. So the person who says good and evil are equal opposites still has to answer the harder question: where does that standard of good come from?

## In full

Defeater for the objection, in three connected forms. **(A) The metaphysical form:** good and evil are two equally real, equally basic principles, so reality is at bottom a balance or a war between them (Zoroastrian and Manichaean dualism; popular readings of yin and yang). **(B) The conceptual form:** good and evil are logical opposites, and opposites need each other, so neither can exist without the other. **(C) The epistemic form:** without evil, good would have no meaning, because we only know good by contrast with evil. In each form the objection is often turned against classical theism: a God who is wholly good, with no evil rival and no evil in himself, is said to be impossible or meaningless.

The reply rests on a distinction that goes back to [Aristotle](/codex/aristotle/)'s *Categories* (ch. 10), which sorts opposites into four kinds: correlatives (double and half), contraries (hot and cold), possession and privation (sight and blindness), and affirmation and negation ("he sits" and "he does not sit"). "Opposite" therefore does not name one relation. Some opposed pairs have two positive poles; others pair a reality with its absence. The classical Christian claim, from [Augustine](/codex/augustine/) through [Thomas Aquinas](/codex/thomas-aquinas/), is that good and evil are the second kind: evil is the privation of a good that is due (see [Privation](/codex/privation/) and [Evil as Privation of Good](/codex/evil-as-privation-of-good/)). The defeat structure is five-pronged: (1) conceptual opposition does not entail that both poles are positive realities; (2) the familiar pairs the objector reaches for, light and dark above all, are privative pairs; (3) good and evil fail every test of symmetry, since evil depends on good and good does not depend on evil; (4) the epistemic form confuses how a thing is recognized with what makes it real; (5) whoever calls anything evil is already using a standard of good, which pushes the question back to the source of that standard and toward the [Moral Argument](/codex/moral-argument/). **This page is structured as debate prep.**

**Honest limits.** The page does not claim that evil is unreal, small, or an illusion. Privations are real: blindness really blinds, and a wound really bleeds. It does not claim the privation account answers why God permits evil; that is the work of [Problem of Evil](/codex/problem-of-evil/) and the free-will and greater-good replies. And it grants that in ordinary moral speech good and evil are rightly called contraries, as Aristotle did. The narrower claim is that their opposition is lopsided: one side is original and the other is parasitic.

## Argument structure

| # | Premise |
|---|---|
| **P1** | Opposition comes in kinds. Two terms can be opposite in meaning while only one names a positive reality; "opposite" alone does not tell you that both sides exist in the same way. |
| **P2** | Many familiar opposites are privative pairs: light and darkness, sound and silence, health and sickness, sight and blindness, knowledge and ignorance, being and nothing. In each, one term is a reality and the other its lack. |
| **P3** | Good and evil behave like a privative pair. Evil always needs a good subject and a good power to work through; good needs no evil. There can be a highest good, but a wholly evil thing would destroy itself. |
| **P4** | The claim that good needs evil in order to be known confuses recognition with existence. Health is real without sickness, truth without lies, and a perfectly good being without any evil. |
| **P5** | To call anything evil is to measure it against a good it falls short of. The objector who uses the word "evil" owes an account of that standard. |
| **C** | **Therefore "good is the opposite of evil" does not show that good and evil are equally real or that good depends on evil. Their opposition is asymmetrical: good is original and evil is its corruption, which is the classical Christian position.** |

## Form

**Defensive (a defeater).** P1 is a **conceptual distinction** drawn from Aristotle's analysis of opposition. P2 supplies **paradigm cases** the objector already accepts. P3 is an **asymmetry argument**: it runs tests of dependence, definition and limit, and good and evil come out lopsided on each. P4 separates **epistemology from ontology**. P5 is a **standard-of-good reductio** that turns the objection's own vocabulary into a question about moral grounding. The argument does not by itself prove God exists. It removes a common reason for thinking a wholly good God without an evil counterpart is incoherent. Soundness is **classical**: the core moves are Augustine's and Aquinas's, and they remain standard in contemporary philosophy of religion.

## Cheatsheet

**The 30-second reply (read aloud).** Sure, good is the opposite of evil, in the same way dark is the opposite of light. But think about what darkness is. Light is real energy. Darkness is the word for where light is missing. You can't pour darkness into a room. Same with silence and sound, or blindness and sight. Those are opposites, but only one side is a real thing; the other is a lack of it. Good and evil work the same way. Every evil needs something good to feed on. A lie needs the gift of speech, and cruelty needs a living person with strength and a will. But good doesn't need evil. You can be healthy without ever being sick. So here's my question back: when you call something evil, what good are you saying it falls short of?

**The 5 fast facts:**

1. **Aristotle listed four kinds of opposites** (*Categories* 10): correlatives, contraries, possession and privation, affirmation and negation. "Opposite" is a family of relations.
2. **Darkness has no physical stuff of its own.** Light is electromagnetic radiation; darkness is the absence of visible light. They are opposites in meaning, but only one is a physical quantity.
3. **Augustine:** "For what is that which we call evil but the absence of good?" (*Enchiridion* 11). And: evil "cannot exist without good," but "Good, however, can exist without evil" (*Enchiridion* 14).
4. **Aquinas:** "there is no one first principle of evil, as there is one first principle of good" (*Summa Theologiae* I q.49 a.3), because a wholly evil thing would destroy itself.
5. **C.S. Lewis:** "badness is only spoiled goodness," and "evil is a parasite, not an original thing" (*Mere Christianity*, Book 2, "The Invasion").

**The 3 strongest counter-moves:**

- *"Is darkness a thing?"* Get agreement that darkness is the absence of light. Then ask whether being opposites requires both sides to exist in the same way. The answer is no, and the objection needs it to be yes.
- *"Name an evil that doesn't use a good."* Lying uses speech, theft uses skill, cruelty uses strength, even hatred uses the power to care intensely. Ask for one evil that runs on its own power.
- *"Could you be healthy without ever being sick?"* If yes, good does not need its opposite in order to exist, and the "you can't have one without the other" premise fails.

**Reciprocal concessions (grant the small point, then collect a bigger one):**

- *Grant:* good and evil really are opposites, and in moral speech they are rightly called contraries. *Now collect:* opposites in meaning can still be lopsided in reality. Light and darkness are opposites, and only one of them is energy.
- *Grant:* we often notice good more sharply after meeting evil. *Now collect:* noticing is about us. It shows how we learn, and says nothing about what good needs in order to be real. A man who recovers from flu notices his health, but his health was not made of flu.
- *Grant:* evil is terribly real, and anyone who has suffered knows it. *Now collect:* then you are describing a wound, and a wound is always a wound *in* something good. Your outrage at evil takes for granted a good that ought to have been there.

**The closing line.** Darkness is the opposite of light, and it is still only the place where light is missing. Evil is the opposite of good, and it is still only good spoiled. You can have light without darkness and good without evil, but never the other way round.

## P1, Opposition comes in kinds

### Affirmative case

1. **"Opposite" is a family word.** Aristotle's *Categories* (ch. 10) distinguishes four ways things are said to be opposed: correlatives (double and half, which are defined by each other), contraries (hot and cold, two positive qualities at opposite ends of a range), possession and privation (sight and blindness), and affirmation and negation (a statement and its denial). Only some of these involve two positive realities.
2. **Meaning and being are different questions.** Whether two words are opposite in meaning is a question about concepts. Whether both words name something that exists in its own right is a question about reality. The objection answers the first and assumes it has answered the second.
3. **Even true contraries do not need each other in every case.** Hot and cold are contraries, but a room can be hot without anything in it being cold. Opposition does not, by itself, create mutual dependence.

### Anticipated objections

1. *"This is word-games. Everyone knows what 'opposite' means."*
2. *"Aristotle himself called good and evil contraries, so the classical tradition is against you."*

### Rebuttals

1. **The distinction is in daily speech already.** Nobody thinks a dark room is full of a substance called darkness, or that a silent room contains silence. People use privative opposites correctly all the time; the objection simply forgets to apply that ordinary competence to good and evil.
2. **Aquinas answers this directly.** In *Summa Theologiae* I q.48 a.1 (reply to objection 1), he grants that Aristotle treats good and evil as genera of contraries, and explains that "every privation, as such, has the nature of evil," just as every form has the nature of good. Good and evil can be contraries in moral talk while evil remains, in being, the absence of good. Aquinas also notes that Aristotle was there reporting the Pythagorean view that evil was a kind of nature.

## P2, The familiar opposites are privative pairs

### Affirmative case

1. **Light and darkness.** Light is electromagnetic radiation with measurable energy. Darkness has no energy, wavelength or particle of its own; it is the absence or reduction of visible light. You can switch light on; there is no switch that emits darkness.
2. **The pattern repeats.** Sound and silence, health and sickness, sight and blindness, knowledge and ignorance, fullness and emptiness, being and nothing. In every pair one term names a positive reality and the other its lack.
3. **The privation is real in its effects.** Blindness really keeps a person from seeing; a hole really lets you fall. So privation is a way of being *real as a lack*, which is why the privation account does not shrink evil.
4. **True dualities do exist, and they look different.** Positive and negative electric charge, attraction and repulsion, subject and object, actuality and potentiality: in these pairs both poles are something positive, and neither is defined as the loss of the other. The question is which kind of pair good and evil are. P3 answers it.

| Pair | Kind | What the second term is |
|---|---|---|
| Positive and negative charge | Two positive poles | A real charge of the other sign |
| North and south magnetic poles | Two aspects of one field | A real pole, inseparable from the first |
| Light and darkness | Privative | The absence of visible light |
| Sound and silence | Privative | The absence of audible sound |
| Health and sickness | Privative | Function lost or disordered |
| Sight and blindness | Privative | Sight missing where it is due |
| Knowledge and ignorance | Privative | Knowledge lacking |
| Good and evil | Privative (the classical claim) | Good missing or corrupted where it is due |

### Anticipated objections

1. *"Cold is just as real as heat, and cold is the opposite of heat."*
2. *"Blindness is not merely an absence; a blind person's experience is a positive state."*

### Rebuttals

1. **Physics agrees with the privative reading here.** Temperature measures thermal energy; "cold" names a lower amount of it, and absolute zero is the limit of its absence. Cold is a convenient word for less heat. Even if one insisted on cold as a quality, the point stands for light and darkness, which the objector chose as the model.
2. **The person is positive; the blindness is the lack in the person.** A blind person has real experiences, abilities and senses, all of them good. Blindness names what is missing from one faculty. That is exactly Aquinas's point that evil exists only "in" a good subject.

## P3, Good and evil fail every test of symmetry

### Affirmative case

1. **The dependence test.** Can evil exist without good? Augustine says no: evil "cannot exist without good, or in anything that is not good." Can good exist without evil? He says yes: "Good, however, can exist without evil" (*Enchiridion* 14). Every evil needs a subject that exists, has powers and has a nature; all three are goods. A lie needs a speaker and the gift of language. Murder needs a living victim whose life is valuable.
2. **The fuel test.** Evil runs on borrowed power. The intelligence of a fraudster, the strength of a bully and the energy of a hater are all good capacities turned to a wrong end. C.S. Lewis argued that nobody pursues badness simply for its own sake; people pursue pleasure, money, power or safety, good things sought in the wrong way, which is why he concluded that "evil is a parasite, not an original thing" (*Mere Christianity*, Book 2, "The Invasion").
3. **The definition test.** Evils are named by the good they damage: injury, disease, deceit, betrayal, injustice. Each is defined as a falling short. Goods are not defined as the falling short of an evil; health is described by what a body does, not by the diseases it lacks.
4. **The limit test.** A highest good is coherent: a being full of life, wisdom and love lacks nothing. A highest evil is not, because a thing that was evil in every respect would have no being, no power and no nature left, so it would not exist to be evil. Aquinas, citing Aristotle, says that "if the wholly evil could be, it would destroy itself," and concludes there is "no one first principle of evil, as there is one first principle of good" (*Summa Theologiae* I q.49 a.3).
5. **The cure test.** When a wound heals, nothing goes anywhere. The wound does not pack up and move house; it simply ceases. Augustine draws exactly this point from disease in *Enchiridion* 11. Goods, by contrast, are added and grow.

### Anticipated objections

1. *"Some evil is plainly positive. A sadist does not lack something; he actively wants another's pain."*
2. *"Zoroastrianism teaches two real spirits, Ahura Mazda and Angra Mainyu, and many people find that more honest than pretending evil is a lack."*
3. *"Yin and yang are equal and complementary. Eastern thought shows good and evil are a balance."*

### Rebuttals

1. **The act is positive; the evil is its disorder.** The sadist has a real will, real attention and real pleasure, all of them good capacities. What makes the act evil is what it lacks: the due ordering of that will to the good of the person in front of him. Aquinas makes exactly this move in *Summa Theologiae* I q.49 a.1, where good causes evil only accidentally, by a deficient exercise of a good power. Positive activity, privative disorder.
2. **Even classical Zoroastrianism is lopsided.** Its own story has Ahura Mazda as the wise creator and expects the destructive spirit to be defeated at the end of history (see [Zoroastrianism](/codex/zoroastrianism/)). Two principles that are unequal in origin and unequal in destiny are not equal opposites. Mani's fully symmetrical version, two eternal kingdoms of light and darkness, is the one Augustine held for years and then rejected for the reasons on this page.
3. **Yin and yang are not good and evil.** In Chinese thought yin and yang are complementary aspects of things, such as shade and sun, rest and motion, receptive and active, and neither is evil. Recruiting them as a picture of moral good and evil misreads them. In fact they fit P2's category of true dualities, two positive poles, which is the opposite of what the objection needs.

## P4, Recognizing good is different from good existing

### Affirmative case

1. **The epistemic claim is about us.** "We only know good by contrast with evil" is a claim about how humans come to notice things. Even if it were fully true, it would describe our learning, and would not show that good needs evil in order to exist.
2. **Counterexamples are easy.** Could someone be healthy without ever having been sick? Could someone tell the truth in a world where nobody had ever lied? Could a child be loved by parents who never wronged her? In each case the good is complete without its opposite.
3. **Contrast is available inside the good.** We notice degrees and kinds of good: a kind word and a heroic sacrifice, a good meal and a great one. Recognition by contrast does not require an evil on the other side; it requires difference, and good is rich in differences.
4. **Applied to God, the claim undoes itself.** If good required evil, then a perfectly good God could not exist unless evil also existed. Classical Christianity holds that God was perfectly good before anything was made, in the eternal love of Father, Son and Holy Spirit, and that "God is light, and in him is no darkness at all" ([1 John 1:5](/codex/1-john-1-5/), ASV). The objector who wants to rule that out has to show why goodness must have an evil partner; repeating that they are opposites does not show it.

### Anticipated objections

1. *"A world without evil would be bland. Good only matters because it might be lost."*
2. *"Without the possibility of evil, there would be no moral choice, so good does need evil."*

### Rebuttals

1. **That is a claim about value, and it backfires.** Saying good "matters" more against the backdrop of loss already treats good as the thing of worth and loss as the threat to it. Christians agree that this world's sorrows sharpen gratitude. That is a point about our condition, and it leaves the order of dependence untouched.
2. **Possibility is different from actuality.** A free creature can fail, so the *possibility* of evil comes with created freedom. That shows good choices by creatures happen where evil is possible, and it shows nothing more. It does not show that any actual evil must exist for good to exist, and God's own goodness involves no such possibility at all.

## P5, Whoever calls something evil is using a standard of good

### Affirmative case

1. **Evil is always "worse than it should be."** To call an act evil is to say it falls short of what it ought to have been: honest speech, faithful love, protection of the weak. That "ought to have been" is the standard.
2. **Equal opposites need a third standard.** C.S. Lewis pressed this against dualism: if there are two equal powers and you call one good and the other bad, you are measuring both against some rule of good that one keeps and the other breaks. Then that rule, and not either power, is the real ultimate. Lewis concluded that dualism, taken seriously, points past itself.
3. **The question goes to grounding.** The objector who says good and evil are opposites, and then condemns cruelty as really evil, owes an account of the good it is measured against. That is the territory of the [Moral Argument](/codex/moral-argument/), [Atheist Moral Realism Defeater](/codex/atheist-moral-realism-defeater/) and [Evolution and Empathy Ground Morality (Defeater)](/codex/evolution-and-empathy-ground-morality-defeater/).

### Anticipated objections

1. *"I can call things evil without believing in God. 'Evil' just means what causes suffering."*

### Rebuttals

1. **Then suffering is being treated as the falling short of a good.** "Causes suffering" is evil only if well-being is good and ought not to be destroyed. That still makes evil the damage of a good, which is the privation structure, and it still leaves the question of why that good binds anyone. The Christian answer is that goodness is grounded in the character of God, the "Father of lights, with whom can be no variation, neither shadow that is cast by turning" ([James 1:17](/codex/james-1-17/), ASV).

## Cross-examination sequence

Use these in order. Each phase aims at one admission.

**Phase 1, what does "opposite" mean?** (Admission: opposition does not require two equal realities.)

1. When you say good is the opposite of evil, do you mean in meaning, in morality, or in what actually exists?
2. Is darkness the opposite of light?
3. Is darkness a substance, or the absence of visible light?
4. So can two things be opposites when one of them is the lack of the other?

**Phase 2, what is evil?** (Admission: evil presupposes a good.)

5. Can anything be evil without some good being damaged or missing?
6. When you call murder evil, is that because a human life is valuable?
7. If life had no value at all, would taking it be wrong?
8. Then does evil presuppose a good it violates?

**Phase 3, does good need evil?** (Admission: good can exist without evil.)

9. Could a person be healthy who was never sick?
10. Could someone tell the truth in a world where no one had ever lied?
11. Does our needing contrast to notice something mean the thing needs contrast to exist?
12. Then could a perfectly good being exist without any evil?

**If they answer "good has no meaning without evil":** "You're mixing up how we tell two ideas apart with what makes either one real. I can understand health better by contrast with disease, but health doesn't need disease to exist."

**Closing question:** "Can you show that because two concepts are opposites, they must both exist as independent realities? Unless you can, 'good is the opposite of evil' does nothing against the Christian view that evil is spoiled good."

## Master objections to the defeater

**MO1: "The privation theory makes evil unreal and trivializes suffering."**

- It does the reverse. A privation is real as a lack: blindness, starvation and a broken heart are all privations, and none is trivial. The theory explains why evil is so destructive: it eats away at real goods. And it keeps evil from being a rival god, which means evil can be defeated. See [Privation](/codex/privation/).

**MO2: "Calling evil a privation is just a definition. You have defined your way out of the problem."**

- The account is supported by tests anyone can run (P3): dependence, fuel, definition, limit and cure. Each one comes out lopsided. A definition that fit the facts this well across every case would count as a discovery. And the classical writers reached it by argument, Augustine after years of holding the opposite view.

**MO3: "If evil is a lack, God is responsible for not filling the lack."**

- That is a different objection, the [Problem of Evil](/codex/problem-of-evil/) proper, and it is answered there and in [God Created Evil Objection Defeater](/codex/god-created-evil-objection-defeater/). This page establishes only that God did not make evil as a thing and that evil cannot stand beside God as an equal. Why God permits creaturely failure is the next question, and it is a fair one.

**MO4: "The Bible says God creates evil" ([Isaiah 45:7](/codex/isaiah-45-7/)).**

- The Hebrew *ra'* there is set against *shalom*, peace, and means calamity or disaster, as most modern translations render it. It describes the judgment God brings on the guilty and says nothing of God manufacturing a moral substance. See [Isaiah 45.7 I Create Evil](/codex/isaiah-45-7-i-create-evil/).

## Tactical opening / closing

**Opening.** I agree good is the opposite of evil. Can I ask what kind of opposite you mean? Because dark is the opposite of light, and darkness isn't a thing; it's where light is missing. I think good and evil work like that, and I'd like to test it with you.

**Closing.** Here's where I land. Evil is real, and it hurts. But every evil I can find is something good gone wrong: speech twisted into lies, strength turned into cruelty, love bent into jealousy. Good doesn't need evil, and evil can't live without good. That's why I don't believe in two equal powers. I believe in one good God and a world he made good, which has been wounded. And when you call something evil, I think you're seeing that too. You're measuring it against a good it should have been. I'd love to talk about where that good comes from.

## Live-cite kit

**Scripture:**

- [1 John 1:5](/codex/1-john-1-5/), "God is light, and in him is no darkness at all." (ASV)
- [James 1:17](/codex/james-1-17/), "Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom can be no variation, neither shadow that is cast by turning." (ASV)
- [Genesis 1:31](/codex/genesis-1-31/), "And God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good." (ASV)
- [Isaiah 5:20](/codex/isaiah-5-20/), "Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness." (ASV)
- [John 1:5](/codex/john-1-5/), "And the light shineth in the darkness; and the darkness apprehended it not." (ASV)
- [Romans 12:21](/codex/romans-12-21/), "Be not overcome of evil, but overcome evil with good." (ASV)

**Patristic and medieval:**

- [Augustine](/codex/augustine/), *Enchiridion* 11, "For what is that which we call evil but the absence of good?"
- Augustine, *Enchiridion* 13-14, "there can be no evil where there is no good"; evil "cannot exist without good"; "Good, however, can exist without evil."
- [Thomas Aquinas](/codex/thomas-aquinas/), *Summa Theologiae* I q.48 a.1, "by the name of evil is signified the absence of good."
- Aquinas, *Summa Theologiae* I q.49 a.3, "there is no one first principle of evil, as there is one first principle of good."
- [Boethius](/codex/boethius/), *Consolation of Philosophy* IV, the wicked as less than they ought to be.

**Scholarly:** Aristotle, *Categories* 10, the four kinds of opposition; [C.S. Lewis](/codex/c-s-lewis/), *Mere Christianity*, Book 2, "The Invasion," on dualism and evil as "spoiled goodness"; Brian Davies, *The Reality of God and the Problem of Evil* (2006); [Edward Feser](/codex/edward-feser/), *Aquinas* (2009).

**Aphorism:** "You can have light without dark, but you can't have dark without a world that was made for light."

**Aphorism:** "Evil can't make anything. It can only spoil what good made."

## Connection to Scripture

- [Genesis 1:31](/codex/genesis-1-31/), creation declared very good before any evil enters.
- [1 John 1:5](/codex/1-john-1-5/) and [James 1:17](/codex/james-1-17/), God as light with no darkness and no shadow.
- [John 1:5](/codex/john-1-5/), light and darkness unequal: the darkness does not overcome the light.
- [Isaiah 5:20](/codex/isaiah-5-20/), the moral danger of swapping good and evil, which presupposes a fixed standard.
- [Romans 12:21](/codex/romans-12-21/), evil overcome with good, never the reverse.

<!-- SCHOLARSHIP:START -->

## Scholarship

Published academic works this page draws on, each matched to a publisher, index or library catalog record.

- Brian Davies, *Reality of God and the Problem of Evil* (2006). [Open Library](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL36018307W)
- C.S. Lewis, *Mere Christianity* (1952). [Open Library](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL43072012W)

<!-- SCHOLARSHIP:END -->

## See also

- [Privation](/codex/privation/), the doctrine of evil as the absence of due good, in full.
- [Evil as Privation of Good](/codex/evil-as-privation-of-good/), the privation argument in debate-prep form.
- [Problem of Evil](/codex/problem-of-evil/), the wider question of why God permits evil.
- [God Created Evil Objection Defeater](/codex/god-created-evil-objection-defeater/), the companion defeater on whether God made evil.
- [Evil God Objection Defeater](/codex/evil-god-objection-defeater/), the symmetry challenge from the other direction.
- [Zoroastrianism](/codex/zoroastrianism/), the best-known cosmic dualism and its own asymmetry.
- [Augustine](/codex/augustine/), the former Manichaean who worked out the privation account.
- [Thomas Aquinas](/codex/thomas-aquinas/), the account's scholastic form.
- [Moral Argument](/codex/moral-argument/), where the standard of good leads.
- [Evolution and Empathy Ground Morality (Defeater)](/codex/evolution-and-empathy-ground-morality-defeater/), on grounding the good the objector appeals to.
- [Isaiah 45.7 I Create Evil](/codex/isaiah-45-7-i-create-evil/), the proof text sometimes raised against the privation view.
- [Atheism](/codex/atheism/), the master hub.

## Common questions this page answers

**Q: Is darkness the opposite of light?**

Yes, in meaning, but they are not two equal things. Light is real energy, electromagnetic radiation, while darkness is the name for the absence of visible light. That makes light and darkness a privative pair, a reality and its lack, which is why they are the classic picture of how good and evil relate.

**Q: Are good and evil equal opposites?**

They are opposites, but they are not equal. Evil always needs some good to exist in and to work through: a lie needs the gift of speech, cruelty needs strength and a will. Good needs no evil at all. Augustine put it this way: evil cannot exist without good, but good can exist without evil.

**Q: Do you need evil to know what good is?**

Contrast can help people notice good, but noticing is a fact about us, and good's existence does not depend on it. A person can be healthy who was never sick, and someone can tell the truth in a world where nobody has ever lied. We also notice good by contrast with other goods, like a kind word and a heroic sacrifice.

**Q: What are true dualities?**

A true duality is a pair in which both sides are something positive, such as positive and negative electric charge, attraction and repulsion, or subject and object. Many pairs that look like dualities are really a reality and its absence: light and darkness, sound and silence, sight and blindness, health and sickness. The classical Christian view puts good and evil in the second group.

**Q: Is yin and yang the same as good and evil?**

No. In Chinese thought yin and yang are complementary aspects of things, such as shade and sun or rest and motion, and neither one is evil. Using them as a picture of moral good and evil misreads the idea. If anything, yin and yang are a true duality of two positive poles, which is a different kind of pair from good and evil.

**Q: Does Christianity teach that God and Satan are equal opposites?**

No. Satan is a created angel who rebelled, so he depends on God for his very existence. Christianity rejects any evil power equal to God. Evil is real, but it has no independent source; it is good corrupted, and in the end it is defeated.

**Q: Could God be good if evil never existed?**

On the Christian view, yes. God was perfectly good before anything was created, in the eternal love of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. If goodness required evil, God's goodness would depend on evil, but nothing about goodness requires that. The claim that good needs evil has to be argued, and the usual argument, that they are opposites, does not show it.

</div>

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:END -->
