# Francis Pascal (Lourdes 1938)

<!-- type: concept | created: 2026-11-17 | updated: 2026-11-17 -->

## Intro

Francis Pascal was a little boy from Beaucaire, a town in the south of France. He was born in October 1934. In December 1937, when he was three, he caught meningitis, an infection of the lining around the brain. When the fever passed, he could not see, he could not use his legs, and his arms were partly paralysed. At least a dozen doctors saw him, and they did not expect him to get better.

In August 1938 his family took him to Lourdes. He was bathed in the spring water twice. After the second bath he could see again, and the paralysis was gone.

The Second World War delayed the medical review. The doctors at Lourdes examined him in October 1946, eight years later, and found him still well. They checked the case again in 1947 and 1948, and in 1949 the Archbishop of Aix declared the cure a miracle. It is the 45th miracle officially recognized at Lourdes. The case is filed in the documented tier because it passed the Lourdes medical process, and the age of the patient matters: a boy of three cannot talk himself into seeing.

![An old black and white postcard of the bath house at Lourdes, a low stone building with arched doors and windows behind tall chestnut trees and iron railings, captioned LOURDES Piscines, with a handwritten line in French down the right edge](/codex/assets/lourdes-piscines-postcard-bnf.jpg)

_The baths (piscines) at Lourdes on an early 20th-century postcard. The handwritten line repeats the words Bernadette reported in 1858, "Allez boire à la fontaine et vous y laver" (go and drink at the spring and wash there). Postcard: Bibliothèque nationale de France, public domain, via [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lourdes_-_Piscines_-_btv1b105709408.jpg)._

**The 30-second version:** Francis Pascal of Beaucaire, born 2 October 1934, was left blind and paralysed in the legs, with partial paralysis of the arms, by meningitis in December 1937. At least a dozen doctors certified the condition, and the prognosis was recorded as "absolutely unfavourable." At Lourdes on 31 August 1938, after his second bath, he recovered his sight and the paralysis left him. The war held up the medical review until 2 October 1946, when the Lourdes Medical Bureau found the cure confirmed, maintained for more than eight years, with no medical explanation possible. The Bureau ratified it again in 1947 and in 1948, after diocesan doctors raised reservations, and Archbishop Charles de Provenchères of Aix declared it miraculous. The Sanctuary lists it as the 45th Lourdes miracle. He was still living in 2008.

## In full

Francis Pascal was born on 2 October 1934 at Beaucaire, in the Gard (Mangiapan and d'Andria, 1987, as reproduced by The Miracle Hunter). In December 1937, aged about three and a quarter, he contracted meningitis, which left him with paralysis of the lower limbs, some paralysis of the upper limbs, and loss of sight. The condition was certified by at least a dozen doctors, and the prognosis was recorded as "absolutely unfavourable." He was taken to Lourdes in August 1938, and on 31 August, "It was after the second Bath that Francis recovered his sight, and lost his paralyses" (Mangiapan and d'Andria). A French reference list states the same facts in brief: "Francis Pascal de Beaucaire (Gard) guérie à 3 ans 10 mois le 31 août 1938 de cécité et paralysie membre inférieur" (Techno-Science.net). The war delayed the first examination by the [Lourdes Medical Bureau](/codex/lourdes-medical-bureau/) until 2 October 1946, when it recorded the cure as confirmed, maintained for more than eight years, and one "for which no medical explanation was possible." A Paris wire report printed in New Zealand that month announced that the Church authorities at Lourdes had accepted the cure of the four-year-old for official registration. The Bureau ratified the cure again in July 1947 and on 1 September 1948, the second time because the diocesan doctors attached to the canonical commission had raised reservations. Charles de Provenchères, Archbishop of Aix from 1945 to 1978, then declared the cure miraculous (Mangiapan and d'Andria's summary gives 31 August 1949 in its text; the Sanctuary's official list gives 31 May 1949). The cure was also reviewed in a peer-reviewed history of the Lourdes cures, which names him among the patients cured between 1918 and 1945 who were still alive in 2008 (François, Sternberg and Fee, *Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences*). Under the Miracles schema the case is Tier 1 on medical-bureau ratification. The Bureau file is not published, the first examination came eight years after the event, and the same historians judge that many interwar Lourdes diagnoses remain doubtful; those limits are set out under Verification.

## Summary

Francis Pascal (born 1934), of Beaucaire in the south of France, was left blind and paralysed in the legs, with partial paralysis of the arms, by meningitis in December 1937. At Lourdes on 31 August 1938, aged 3 years and 10 months, he recovered his sight and the use of his limbs after his second bath. The Lourdes Medical Bureau examined him in October 1946, found the cure maintained for more than eight years and medically unexplained, and ratified it again in 1947 and 1948. Archbishop Charles de Provenchères of Aix declared it miraculous in 1949. It is the 45th cure recognized as a miracle at Lourdes, and he was still living in 2008.

## The event

1. **Birth.** Francis Pascal was born on 2 October 1934 at Beaucaire, Gard (Mangiapan and d'Andria).
2. **The illness.** In December 1937, aged about three and a quarter, he contracted meningitis. It left him with paralysis of the lower limbs, partial paralysis of the upper limbs, and loss of sight (Mangiapan and d'Andria).
3. **The doctors.** The condition was certified by at least a dozen doctors before he went to Lourdes, and the prognosis was recorded as "absolutely unfavourable" (Mangiapan and d'Andria).
4. **August 1938.** His family took him to Lourdes, where he was bathed in the piscines, the baths fed from the spring at the Grotto.
5. **31 August 1938, the second bath.** "It was after the second Bath that Francis recovered his sight, and lost his paralyses" (Mangiapan and d'Andria). He was 3 years and 10 months old (Techno-Science.net).
6. **The war.** The Second World War delayed the medical examination for eight years.
7. **2 October 1946, the Medical Bureau.** The Bureau recorded the cure as confirmed, maintained for more than eight years, with no medical explanation possible (Mangiapan and d'Andria).
8. **October 1946, the press.** A Paris wire report printed in a New Zealand paper dated 31 October 1946 announced that the Church authorities at Lourdes had accepted the cure of Francois Pascal, aged four, blind and paralysed in arms and legs when he came to Lourdes in 1938, for official registration (Papers Past).
9. **July 1947 and 1 September 1948, further ratification.** The Bureau ratified the cure again in July 1947, and once more on 1 September 1948 because the diocesan doctors attached to the canonical commission had raised reservations (Mangiapan and d'Andria). What those reservations were is not recorded in the sources found.
10. **1949, the declaration.** Archbishop Charles de Provenchères of Aix declared the cure miraculous, attributing it to the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary (Mangiapan and d'Andria). The Sanctuary's list enters it as number 45, recognized 31 May 1949.
11. **Afterward.** François, Sternberg and Fee list him among the Lourdes patients cured between 1918 and 1945 who were still living in 2008, seventy years after the cure.

## Witnesses + documentation

- **Francis Pascal**, the patient, aged 3 at the time of the cure.
- **His parents**, who brought him to Lourdes; unnamed in the accounts found.
- **The certifying doctors**, "at least a dozen" by the Lourdes summary; unnamed in the accounts found.
- **The Lourdes Medical Bureau**, which examined him on 2 October 1946 and ratified the cure in July 1947 and on 1 September 1948.
- **The diocesan doctors of the canonical commission**, whose reservations prompted the 1948 re-examination; unnamed in the accounts found.
- **Charles de Provenchères**, Archbishop of Aix (1945 to 1978), who declared the cure miraculous.
- **The 1946 press report**, a Paris wire item printed in New Zealand, independent of the Sanctuary's own publications.
- **Bernard François, Esther M. Sternberg and Elizabeth Fee**, whose peer-reviewed history of the Lourdes cures (2012) names the case and records that he was alive in 2008.

## Verification

**What was checked:**

1. **The recognition.** The Sanctuary of Lourdes' official list enters "Francis PASCAL from Beaucaire (France)" as number 45, with "Date of recognition : 31st May 1949."
2. **The date and age.** The Lourdes summary gives birth on 2 October 1934 and the cure on 31 August 1938; the French reference list gives "3 ans 10 mois le 31 août 1938," which matches those two dates exactly.
3. **The diagnosis.** The Lourdes summary, the French list, and the peer-reviewed history all give blindness and paralysis following meningitis ("postmeningitis paraplegia and blindness," François, Sternberg and Fee).
4. **The archbishop.** Charles de Provenchères held the see of Aix from November 1945 until his retirement in November 1978, so he was the archbishop in 1949.
5. **An outside record.** The 1946 wire report shows the Bureau's finding was public within weeks of the examination and gives the same picture: a four-year-old, blind and paralysed in arms and legs, at Lourdes in 1938.
6. **Durability.** The cure was found maintained after eight years in 1946, and he was still living in 2008.

**Naturalistic explanations considered:**

- **Natural recovery after meningitis.** This is the strongest natural explanation and should be stated plainly. Blindness after meningitis in young children is often cortical, caused by injury to the brain's visual areas, and some children recover sight partly or fully over the following months. Paralysis after meningitis can also improve with time. Eight months passed between the illness and the cure, so gradual natural recovery is a live possibility. Against it, the summary records a sudden recovery of both sight and movement after the second bath, a prognosis that a dozen doctors judged absolutely unfavourable, and complete recovery that held for decades. The doctors who reviewed the file judged it medically unexplained, but the file is not public.
- **Suggestion or hysteria.** Functional blindness and paralysis are recognized in adults, and critics of Lourdes have often invoked them. They fit a child of three poorly: he had a documented organic illness as the cause, and he was too young to expect or perform a cure.
- **Misdiagnosis.** If the deficits were milder than certified, the cure would be less remarkable. The number of certifying doctors weighs against this, but none of the certificates have been published.

**Caveats and remaining uncertainties:**

- **No examination at the time.** The Bureau first saw him eight years after the cure, so the clinical picture before and at the moment of the cure rests on the earlier certificates, which are not published.
- **The historians' verdict on the period.** François, Sternberg and Fee conclude that "Most cures that occurred between the two World Wars cannot be accepted at face value" and that "Many diagnoses remain dubious for lack of appropriate criteria and follow-up." They name this case without assessing it individually.
- **Reservations within the process.** The diocesan doctors raised reservations that required a further ratification in 1948. Their content is not known.
- **Unnamed witnesses.** The parents, the certifying doctors and the Bureau physicians are not named in the accounts found.

## Tensions

The published accounts differ on several points. They are recorded here, attributed, without choosing a winner.

- **Recognition date.** The Sanctuary's list gives 31 May 1949. The Lourdes summary as reproduced by The Miracle Hunter gives 31 May 1949 in its heading and 31 August 1949 in its text. The 1946 wire report already speaks of the cure being accepted for official registration, which reflects the Bureau's 1946 finding; the archbishop's declaration came in 1949.
- **His town.** The Sanctuary and the Lourdes summary give Beaucaire, in the Gard. The digitized text of the 1946 wire report gives Apt as the town he came from.
- **His age.** He was 3 years and 10 months old at the cure by the birth date in the Lourdes summary; the wire report and the peer-reviewed history call him four, and the summary says "in his fourth year."
- **His name.** The Sanctuary gives Francis; the 1946 report gives Francois.

## Apologetic value

- **A child cannot fake a cure.** The common reply to Lourdes is suggestion. A three-year-old with a documented infection of the brain's lining is a poor fit for that explanation, which makes the case useful against the "it was all in the mind" reply.
- **Two independent faculties restored together.** Sight and movement both returned after the second bath. A single natural recovery that restores both at the same moment is less likely than a gradual return of one.
- **Durable for seventy years.** The cure was found maintained after eight years and the patient was alive in 2008.
- **Scrutinized more than once.** The Bureau confirmed it in 1946, again in 1947, and again in 1948 after its own diocesan doctors objected. A process that pauses on internal objection is a filter, and Lourdes has recognized only about seventy cures in more than a century and a half.
- **Read in biblical terms.** Jesus answered John the Baptist that "The blind receive their sight, and the lame walk" ([Matthew 11:5](/codex/matthew-11-5/), KJV), and of children he said, "Suffer the little children to come unto me" ([Mark 10:14](/codex/mark-10-14/), KJV). Catholic recognition attributes the cure to the intercession of Our Lady of Lourdes; Protestant readers will attribute it to God answering prayer. Both agree that the healing comes from God.
- **Honest limits.** The diagnosis rests on unpublished certificates, the Bureau saw him only years later, and natural recovery after childhood meningitis is a real possibility. The case is one strand in a cumulative case. See [Argument from Miracles](/codex/argument-from-miracles/).
- **How to deploy it.** Lead with the patient's age and the cause of his illness, which answer the suggestion reply. Then concede natural recovery after meningitis openly, point to the timing, the double recovery and the seventy-year outcome, and ask which explanation fits the whole record best.

## Scholarship

Published academic works this page draws on, each matched to a publisher, index or library catalog record.

- B. Francois, E. M. Sternberg and E. Fee, "The Lourdes Medical Cures Revisited," *Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences* 69 (2014). [doi:10.1093/jhmas/jrs041](https://doi.org/10.1093/jhmas/jrs041) [PubMed 22843835](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22843835/)

<!-- SCHOLARSHIP:END -->

## See also

- [Miracles](/codex/miracles/), master hub
- _schema, the vetting standard this entry follows
- [Lourdes Medical Bureau](/codex/lourdes-medical-bureau/), the body that examined the case
- [Bernadette Soubirous](/codex/bernadette-soubirous/), the visionary of Lourdes
- [Delizia Cirolli (Lourdes 1976)](/codex/delizia-cirolli-lourdes-1976/), another child cured at Lourdes, of a bone tumour
- [Jeanne Fretel (Lourdes 1948)](/codex/jeanne-fretel-lourdes-1948/), a cure from the same post-war years of Lourdes recognitions
- [Gabriel Gargam (Lourdes 1901)](/codex/gabriel-gargam-lourdes-1901/), another paralysis reversed at Lourdes
- [Argument from Miracles](/codex/argument-from-miracles/), the argument this case supports
- [David Hume](/codex/david-hume/), whose standard for credible miracle testimony this case presses on
- [Naturalism](/codex/naturalism/), the worldview such cases press against

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:START -->

<div data-pagefind-weight="5">

## Common questions this page answers

**Q: What was the 45th miracle of Lourdes?**

It was the cure of Francis Pascal of Beaucaire, France, a boy left blind and paralysed by meningitis. He recovered his sight and the use of his limbs after his second bath at Lourdes on 31 August 1938, and the Sanctuary lists the cure as recognized on 31 May 1949.

**Q: Who was Francis Pascal?**

He was a French boy born on 2 October 1934 at Beaucaire. Meningitis in December 1937 left him blind and paralysed, and he was cured at Lourdes at the age of 3 years and 10 months. He was still living in 2008.

**Q: How was Francis Pascal's cure investigated?**

The war delayed the review, so the Lourdes Medical Bureau first examined him on 2 October 1946 and found the cure maintained for more than eight years with no medical explanation. It ratified the cure again in 1947 and in 1948 after diocesan doctors raised reservations, and Archbishop Charles de Provenchères of Aix then declared it miraculous.

**Q: Could Francis Pascal have recovered naturally from meningitis?**

It is the main natural explanation, since some children regain sight and movement in the months after meningitis. Against it, the record describes a sudden recovery of both sight and movement after the second bath, a prognosis a dozen doctors judged absolutely unfavourable, and a cure that lasted for decades. The certificates and the Bureau file are not published, so outside readers cannot check them.

**Q: Why does a child's cure at Lourdes matter?**

The most common skeptical reply to Lourdes cures is suggestion, the idea that patients talk themselves into recovery. A three-year-old with a documented brain infection is a poor fit for that reply, which is why cures of young children are often cited in discussions of Lourdes.

</div>

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:END -->
