# Elisa Aloi (Lourdes 1958)

<!-- type: concept | created: 2026-11-15 | updated: 2026-11-15 -->

## Intro

Elisa Aloi was a young Sicilian woman, born in 1931, who lost both parents as a child. As a teenager she caught tuberculosis of the bones and joints in her right leg. For about ten years it spread from joint to joint, with open, draining wounds that would not heal. She had many operations, and by 1958 she lay in a plaster cast, unable to stand.

On 5 June 1958 she was carried to the pools at Lourdes. She later said she felt an emptying sensation and then her legs moving inside the cast. Back in Messina, the cast was taken off, the wounds were closed, and X-rays showed the bone of her thigh whole.

The doctors at Lourdes recognized the cure, an international panel of doctors found it medically unexplained, and on 26 May 1965 the Archbishop of Messina declared it a miracle. It is the 61st miracle officially recognized at Lourdes. She married, had four children, and lived to 89. The case is filed in the documented tier because it passed the full Lourdes medical process.

![An old black-and-white postcard of the bathing pavilion at Lourdes, a gabled building with tall arched windows behind a low railing and trees, with two men standing in front, captioned Lourdes, Les Piscines](/codex/assets/lourdes-les-piscines-postcard-c1905.jpg)

_The pools at Lourdes on a postcard of about 1905, half a century before Elisa Aloi was carried to them. Photo: unknown photographer (H. B. 137), public domain, via [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Lourdes-les_piscines-HB_137.jpg)._

**The 30-second version:**

> Elisa Aloi, a Sicilian woman born in 1931, had tuberculosis of the bones and joints of her right leg for about ten years, with draining fistulae and many failed operations. In June 1958 she went to Lourdes encased in plaster. On 5 June she was taken to the pools, felt her legs move inside the cast, and soon after her fistulae were found closed. Her surgeon wrote that she had "returned from Lourdes completely cured." The Lourdes Medical Bureau recognized the cure, the International Medical Committee judged it medically inexplicable, and Archbishop Francesco Fasola of Messina declared it the 61st Lourdes miracle on 26 May 1965. She married, bore four children, and died in 2020 at 89.

## In full

Elisa Aloi was born on 26 November 1931 in Patti, Sicily (Mangiapan and d'Andria, 1987, as reproduced by The Miracle Hunter). Her parents died when she was eleven (*SuperAbile*, December 2013). As a teenager she developed tuberculous arthritis of the right knee, a "white swelling" in the older medical term, and in the following ten years tuberculous infections spread to further bones and joints, with fistulae that required repeated hospital and sanatorium care (Mangiapan and d'Andria). The published summary of the [Lourdes Medical Bureau](/codex/lourdes-medical-bureau/)'s recognized cases describes "tuberculous osteoarthritis with fistulae at multiple sites in the right leg" (Wikipedia, "Lourdes Medical Bureau"). She went to Lourdes with the Sicilian pilgrimage of UNITALSI, the Italian association that takes the sick to Lourdes, and on 5 June 1958, in a plaster cast with draining fistulae, she was taken to the pools (Aleteia, 22 November 2020; *SuperAbile*). Her fistulae were afterwards found closed, and her surgeon wrote, about ten days after she left Sicily, that she had "returned from Lourdes completely cured" (Mangiapan and d'Andria). The Bureau recognized the cure and passed the dossier to the International Medical Committee of Lourdes (CMIL) in 1960, which adopted a report by Professor Salmon finding the cure medically inexplicable. After a favourable report from a canonical commission, Archbishop Francesco Fasola of Messina declared the cure miraculous on 26 May 1965 (Mangiapan and d'Andria). The Sanctuary's official list enters her as number 61, "Elisa ALOI from Patti (Italy)," recognized 26 May 1965. Under the Miracles schema the case is Tier 1 on medical-bureau ratification. The Bureau and CMIL files are not published online, and the published accounts differ on several details, set out under Tensions below.

## Summary

Elisa Aloi (1931 to 2020), from Patti in Sicily, had tuberculous osteoarthritis with fistulae at several sites in the right leg for about a decade, despite many operations. On 5 June 1958, aged 26, she was cured at Lourdes after being taken to the pools during a UNITALSI pilgrimage; her surgeon in Sicily confirmed the cure, and later X-rays showed the right femur whole. The Lourdes Medical Bureau recognized the cure, the International Medical Committee of Lourdes judged it medically inexplicable after receiving the dossier in 1960, and Archbishop Francesco Fasola of Messina declared it miraculous on 26 May 1965. It is the 61st cure recognized as a miracle at Lourdes.

## The event

1. **The illness.** Her tuberculosis began with a "white swelling" of the right knee, tuberculous arthritis, when she was nearly seventeen by one account (Mangiapan and d'Andria) or fourteen by her own later account (*SuperAbile*, 2013). Over about ten years, up to 1958, it spread to further bones and joints with fistulae, and she was treated in hospitals and sanatoria (Mangiapan and d'Andria). She had lost her parents at eleven: "La più grande sofferenza per me era essere sola" ("The greatest suffering for me was being alone") (*SuperAbile*).
2. **Surgery and the cast.** She underwent 33 operations, and ten centimetres of her right femur were removed in an attempt to stop the infection (*SuperAbile*). By 1958 she was immobilized in plaster and confined to lying on her back (*SuperAbile*; Mangiapan and d'Andria).
3. **An earlier visit without result.** She had been to Lourdes before, in June 1957 with the UNITALSI pilgrimage from Sicily, without improvement (Mangiapan and d'Andria). In 1958 she returned in a worse state, with four fistulae draining through the cast.
4. **5 June 1958.** She had a high fever and asked to be carried to the pools on a stretcher (*SuperAbile*). She described what she felt: "Ho avvertito un senso di svuotamento, poi le gambe dentro al gesso che si muovevano, e ho pensato a una suggestione" ("I felt a sense of emptying, then my legs moving inside the cast, and I thought it was suggestion") (*SuperAbile*). She had not been asking to be healed: "Non chiedevo la guarigione" ("I was not asking for healing") (*SuperAbile*).
5. **The doctors at Lourdes.** The doctors found the fistulae closed and the gauze and drainage tubes beside her legs clean, and sent her back to the hospital in Messina to have the cast removed (*SuperAbile*).
6. **Messina.** X-rays showed the right femur, from which ten centimetres had been removed, complete, and her surgeon told her she had nothing wrong, "neanche tracce di decalcificazione" ("not even traces of decalcification") (*SuperAbile*). In writing, the surgeon recorded that she had "returned from Lourdes completely cured" (Mangiapan and d'Andria).
7. **The Bureau and the CMIL.** The Lourdes Medical Bureau recognized the cure and passed the dossier to the CMIL in 1960; Professor Salmon, the committee's rapporteur, presented a report of a medically inexplicable cure, and the committee adopted it (Mangiapan and d'Andria).
8. **The declaration.** After a favourable report from the canonical commission, Archbishop Francesco Fasola of Messina declared the cure miraculous on 26 May 1965 (Mangiapan and d'Andria). The Sanctuary lists the recognition under that date.
9. **Afterward.** She married a few months after the recognition and had four children between 1966 and 1974, which the Lourdes summary calls the best evidence that the cure was complete (Mangiapan and d'Andria). She served for decades as a UNITALSI volunteer (*SuperAbile*), and she died on 21 November 2020, aged 89 (Aleteia).

## Witnesses + documentation

- **Elisa Aloi**, the patient, who gave her own account in later interviews.
- **The UNITALSI pilgrimage from Sicily**, which took her to Lourdes in 1957 and 1958; its members are not named in the published accounts.
- **The doctors at Lourdes** who examined the closed fistulae on the spot, unnamed in the accounts found.
- **Her surgeon in Messina**, who removed the cast, read the X-rays and wrote that she had returned completely cured; the accounts found do not give his name.
- **The Lourdes Medical Bureau**, which recognized the cure.
- **The International Medical Committee of Lourdes (CMIL)**, which received the dossier in 1960 and adopted Professor Salmon's report.
- **Archbishop Francesco Fasola of Messina** (archbishop 1963 to 1977), who declared the cure miraculous on 26 May 1965.

## Verification

**What was checked:**

1. **The recognition.** The Sanctuary of Lourdes' official list of recognized cures enters "Elisa ALOI from Patti (Italy)" as number 61, with "Date of recognition : 26th May 1965." The Wikipedia summary of the Bureau's cases gives the same date, the visit of 5 June 1958, age 27, Patti, and "tuberculous osteoarthritis with fistulae at multiple sites in the right leg."
2. **The date of the cure.** Aleteia (2020) gives 5 June 1958 at Lourdes; *SuperAbile* (2013) gives 5 June 1958 in her own account; Mangiapan and d'Andria give 5 June 1958.
3. **The archbishop.** Francesco Fasola was Archbishop of Messina from 1963 to 1977, so he held the see in May 1965.
4. **The illness and its duration.** All accounts agree on multiple bone and joint tuberculosis of the right leg, with fistulae, lasting about ten years and treated by repeated surgery.
5. **Durability.** She married, bore four children between 1966 and 1974, volunteered with UNITALSI into her eighties, and lived until 2020, sixty-two years after the cure.

**Naturalistic explanations considered:**

- **Late effect of treatment.** Antibiotic treatment of tuberculosis was available in the 1950s and can heal bone tuberculosis over months. Against this, the infection had progressed for a decade through many operations, and the accounts describe closure of several draining fistulae found at Lourdes itself, followed by an X-ray picture her surgeon could not explain. The CMIL, which saw the records, judged the cure medically inexplicable. Its report is not public, so an outside reader cannot check how it weighed her prior treatment.
- **Suggestion.** She herself first thought what she felt was suggestion. Suggestion can change pain and movement, but it does not close tuberculous fistulae or restore bone, which are the findings the accounts report.
- **Spontaneous remission.** Tuberculous lesions can become inactive. The reported speed, from a draining, febrile state to closed fistulae within the pilgrimage, and the restored femur are what the medical review found exceptional.

**Caveats and remaining uncertainties:**

- **No published report.** No Bureau file, CMIL report or medical case report has been found online. The clinical picture rests on the Lourdes summary and on her later interviews.
- **Unnamed surgeon.** The surgeon's written statement is quoted, but his name is not given in the accounts found.
- **The femur claim.** The statement that ten centimetres of femur had been removed and were found restored comes from her own account in 2013 as reported by *SuperAbile*. The Lourdes summary as reproduced does not mention it. It is reported here as her account, not as a finding of the Bureau.

## Tensions

The published accounts differ on several points. They are recorded here, attributed, without choosing a winner.

- **Age at onset.** Mangiapan and d'Andria put the onset when she was nearly seventeen; she said fourteen in 2013 (*SuperAbile*).
- **Which visit.** Mangiapan and d'Andria describe 1958 as her second visit after June 1957; *SuperAbile* reports it as her third time at Lourdes.
- **How the water was used.** Mangiapan and d'Andria say her dressings were soaked in Lourdes water during the pilgrimage; Aleteia (2020) says she was immersed in one of the pools, and her own account has her carried to the pools on a stretcher. Both may describe the same days; the sources do not say.
- **The extent of the cast.** One account describes a cast from pelvis to foot (Mangiapan and d'Andria); her own account describes one from neck to right thigh (*SuperAbile*).
- **Her age.** She was born on 26 November 1931, so she was 26 on 5 June 1958; Mangiapan and d'Andria say "in her 27th year," and Aleteia and the Wikipedia summary say 27.
- **Her married name.** Wikipedia gives "Varcalli," Aleteia "Varacalli."

## Apologetic value

- **An organic disease with visible signs.** Tuberculous fistulae are open, draining wounds that anyone can see. Their closure is not a matter of how the patient feels. That makes this case harder to explain by suggestion than cures of pain or paralysis.
- **She did not ask for it.** By her own account she was not praying for healing, and her first thought was that the sensation was suggestion. That cuts against the claim that expectation produced the cure.
- **Durable for sixty-two years.** She married, bore four children and worked as a volunteer for decades. A temporary remission does not explain a life like that.
- **Passed the strictest filter available.** Lourdes has recognized only about seventy cures in more than a century and a half. This one went through the Medical Bureau and the CMIL before the archbishop acted.
- **Read in biblical terms.** A woman who "had suffered many things of many physicians ... and was nothing bettered" ([Mark 5:26](/codex/mark-5-26/)) fits her thirty-three operations exactly, and the cure fits Jesus' summary of his works, "the lame walk" ([Matthew 11:5](/codex/matthew-11-5/)). Catholic recognition attributes the cure to the intercession of Our Lady of Lourdes; Protestant readers will attribute it to God answering prayer, and both agree that the healing comes from God.
- **Honest limits.** The case files are not public, the surgeon is unnamed, and the accounts disagree on several details. Use it as one strand in a cumulative case, not as a stand-alone proof. See [Argument from Miracles](/codex/argument-from-miracles/).
- **How to deploy it.** Lead with the visible facts: ten years of draining fistulae, many operations, a plaster cast on the way there, closed wounds found at Lourdes, and four children afterwards. Then concede that the files are unpublished, and ask which natural process closes several tuberculous fistulae within a pilgrimage and keeps them closed for life.

## See also

- [Miracles](/codex/miracles/), master hub
- _schema, the vetting standard this entry follows
- [Lourdes Medical Bureau](/codex/lourdes-medical-bureau/), the body that investigated the case, and the CMIL above it
- [Bernadette Soubirous](/codex/bernadette-soubirous/), the visionary of Lourdes
- [Marie Bailly (Lourdes 1902)](/codex/marie-bailly-lourdes-1902/), another tuberculous illness cured at the pools
- [Vittorio Micheli (Lourdes 1962)](/codex/vittorio-micheli-lourdes-1962/), another Italian cure in which destroyed bone was found restored
- [Antonietta Raco (Lourdes 2009)](/codex/antonietta-raco-lourdes-2009/), another Italian cure on a UNITALSI pilgrimage
- [Argument from Miracles](/codex/argument-from-miracles/), the argument this case supports
- [David Hume](/codex/david-hume/), whose standard for credible miracle testimony this case presses on
- [Naturalism](/codex/naturalism/), the worldview such cases press against

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:START -->

<div data-pagefind-weight="5">

## Common questions this page answers

**Q: What was the 61st miracle of Lourdes?**

It was the cure of Elisa Aloi, a Sicilian woman from Patti, of tuberculosis of the bones and joints of her right leg with draining fistulae. She was cured at Lourdes on 5 June 1958, and Archbishop Francesco Fasola of Messina declared the cure miraculous on 26 May 1965.

**Q: Who was Elisa Aloi?**

She was an Italian woman, born in Patti, Sicily, on 26 November 1931, who had bone and joint tuberculosis for about ten years and was cured at Lourdes in 1958. She married, had four children, served as a UNITALSI volunteer for decades, and died on 21 November 2020 at 89.

**Q: How was Elisa Aloi's cure investigated?**

The Lourdes Medical Bureau recognized the cure and sent the dossier to the International Medical Committee of Lourdes in 1960, which adopted a report finding it medically inexplicable. A canonical commission then reported favourably, and the Archbishop of Messina declared it a miracle in 1965.

**Q: Could Elisa Aloi's tuberculosis have healed naturally?**

Bone tuberculosis can heal slowly with treatment, and that is the main natural explanation. Against it, her disease had progressed for ten years through many operations, and several draining fistulae were found closed during the pilgrimage itself. The doctors who reviewed the records judged the cure medically inexplicable, though their reports are not published.

</div>

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:END -->
