# Benedicta McCarthy (Edith Stein 1987)

<!-- type: concept | created: 2026-11-15 | updated: 2026-11-15 -->


## Intro

In March 1987 a two-year-old girl named Benedicta McCarthy, from Brockton, Massachusetts, swallowed a large amount of Tylenol from free sample packets at home. The poison attacked her liver and kidneys. She was moved to Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston, where her liver swelled to about five times its normal size, her kidneys failed, and she caught a serious infection. Doctors got ready for a liver transplant, but no liver was available. Her doctor, Dr. Ronald Kleinman, later said he did not expect her to recover.

Benedicta was named after Edith Stein, a Jewish-born philosopher who became a Carmelite nun and was murdered at Auschwitz in 1942. Her family and friends started a prayer chain asking Edith Stein to pray for her. Within days she came out of danger, and her liver returned to normal size. She went home well.

Dr. Kleinman testified about the case in Boston and in Rome. The Vatican accepted the recovery as a miracle in 1997, and Pope John Paul II declared Edith Stein a saint on 11 October 1998. Benedicta, then fourteen, was there. The case is filed in the documented tier because it passed the Vatican's formal medical and theological review.

![A black-and-white head-and-shoulders portrait of a woman in a woven cloche hat with a pale band and a light blouse, looking toward the camera with a slight smile](/codex/assets/edith-stein-portrait-c1920.jpg)

_Edith Stein around 1920, years before she became Sister Teresia Benedicta of the Cross. Photo: unknown author, public domain, via [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Saint_Edith_Stein.jpg)._

**The 30-second version:**

> In March 1987 Benedicta McCarthy, aged two and a half, swallowed a large dose of Tylenol. At Massachusetts General Hospital her liver swelled to five times normal size, her kidneys failed, she had a staph infection, and doctors prepared for a liver transplant that never came. Her doctor, Ronald Kleinman, said he did not expect her to recover. Her family prayed to Edith Stein, her namesake. Within days she recovered completely. Kleinman testified in Boston and before a medical panel in Rome. The Vatican recognized the miracle in April 1997, and Edith Stein was canonized on 11 October 1998.

## In full

Edith Stein was born in Breslau (now Wrocław, Poland) on 12 October 1891 to a Jewish family. She became a philosopher in the phenomenological school, converted to Catholicism, and entered the Carmel in Cologne as Sister Teresia Benedicta of the Cross. Deported from the Netherlands with her sister Rosa and other Catholics of Jewish descent, she was killed at Auschwitz, probably on 9 August 1942 (Vatican biography). She was beatified in Cologne on 1 May 1987 as a martyr, so no miracle was required for that step. Canonization required one verified miracle, and the McCarthy case supplied it.

The clinical picture comes from press accounts that quote the treating physician. The *Washington Post* (May 1997) reports that she had seizures after taking the Tylenol, was transferred from a local hospital to Massachusetts General Hospital, and there had failing kidneys, a liver about five times normal size and a staph infection. Doctors prepared for a liver transplant, but no liver was available. Dr. Ronald Kleinman, a pediatric gastroenterologist, told the paper, "I did not expect her to recover from this." The Associated Press (April 1997) reports that she "barely clung to life for four days" as her liver and kidneys failed and she drifted toward a coma. *Inside the Vatican* (October 1998) reports a doctor's note at 2:00 p.m. on 24 March 1987, four days after the poisoning: "This child has made a remarkable recovery."

The church process ran for a decade. Kleinman testified for over five hours at a hearing of the Archdiocese of Boston in 1992 and later before a panel of doctors and clergy of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints in Rome (National Post, 2010; *Washington Post*, 1997). The Vatican announced on 8 April 1997 that Pope John Paul II had recognized the miracle (AP). John Paul II canonized Teresa Benedicta of the Cross in St Peter's Square on 11 October 1998 (Vatican homily). Under the Miracles schema the case is Tier 1 on the ground of Vatican ratification. It has no published medical case report, and the medical file is not public.

## Summary

Teresia Benedicta McCarthy, born 8 August 1984 to the Rev. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy, an Eastern Rite Catholic priest, and Mary McCarthy of Brockton, Massachusetts, swallowed a large dose of Tylenol on 20 March 1987, aged two and a half. Treated at Massachusetts General Hospital, she developed liver failure, kidney failure and an infection, and doctors prepared for a liver transplant. Her family organized a prayer chain asking the intercession of Blessed Teresia Benedicta of the Cross (Edith Stein), her namesake, beatified six weeks later. She recovered within days. Her physician, Dr. Ronald Kleinman, testified in Boston (1992) and in Rome. The Vatican recognized the cure as a miracle on 8 April 1997, and Edith Stein was canonized on 11 October 1998.

## The event

1. **The name.** The McCarthys learned of Edith Stein in 1983, and named their daughter, born 8 August 1984, after Stein's religious name (*Washington Post*, 1997). The AP notes that 8 August in Massachusetts was already 9 August in Auschwitz time, the anniversary of Stein's death.
2. **The poisoning.** On Friday, 20 March 1987 (*Inside the Vatican*, 1998; National Post, 2010), while the family was sick with the flu and her parents were away (ABC News, 2010), she tore open free sample packets of Tylenol the family had been given and swallowed the contents (*Washington Post*, 1997).
3. **The crisis.** She had seizures and was transferred from her local hospital to Massachusetts General Hospital. Her kidneys failed, her liver swelled to about five times normal size, and she developed a staph infection (*Washington Post*, 1997). She drifted toward a coma (AP, 1997). Doctors prepared for a liver transplant, but no liver was available (*Washington Post*, 1997); her mother recalled that she was put on a priority transplant list (*Deseret News*, 1998).
4. **The prognosis.** Kleinman did not expect her to survive but did not tell her parents: "I almost never tell the parent there is no hope" (National Post, 2010).
5. **The prayer.** Her mother's sister, Teresa Smit, in Wisconsin, helped start a prayer chain asking Edith Stein's intercession (*Washington Post*, 1997). Her parents prayed to Stein as soon as they realized how sick she was (National Post, 2010).
6. **The recovery.** Within days she came out of the coma and her liver returned to normal size (*Washington Post*, 1997). A doctor's note at 2:00 p.m. on 24 March read, "This child has made a remarkable recovery" (*Inside the Vatican*, 1998). Benedicta later said, "Like there was no gradual recovery" (ABC News, 2010). A contemporaneous article from 1987, reproduced on her father's website, describes her a few weeks later as "a happy, healthy little two-year-old."
7. **Recognition.** The Vatican announced the papal recognition of the miracle on 8 April 1997 (AP). Benedicta, aged fourteen, attended the canonization in Rome on 11 October 1998 with her parents and siblings (*Deseret News*, 1998).

## Witnesses + documentation

- **Teresia Benedicta McCarthy**, the patient, who recalled the case in a 2010 ABC News interview.
- **The Rev. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy and Mary McCarthy**, her parents, quoted by the AP (1997), the *Washington Post* (1997) and the *Deseret News* (1998).
- **Teresa Smit**, her aunt, who helped start the prayer chain (*Washington Post*, 1997).
- **Dr. Ronald Kleinman**, pediatric gastroenterologist at Massachusetts General Hospital, who treated her and testified at both stages of the inquiry. He is described as Jewish (*Inside the Vatican*, 1998) and as an atheist who does not "believe in miracles in the Catholic sense" (National Post, 2010).
- **The Archdiocese of Boston**, whose hearing took Kleinman's testimony in 1992 (National Post, 2010).
- **The Congregation for the Causes of Saints**, whose panel of doctors and clergy in Rome questioned Kleinman (*Washington Post*, 1997) and which reached its decision by unanimous vote (*Inside the Vatican*, 1998).
- **Father Simeon of the Holy Family, OCD**, postulator general of the Discalced Carmelites, who presented the cause (*Inside the Vatican*, 1998).
- **Pope John Paul II**, who recognized the miracle (announced 8 April 1997) and canonized Edith Stein on 11 October 1998.

## Verification

**What was checked:**

1. **The canonization.** The Vatican's published text of John Paul II's homily of 11 October 1998 records the canonization of Teresa Benedicta of the Cross in St Peter's Square.
2. **The beatification and biography.** The Vatican's official biography confirms her birth in Breslau on 12 October 1891, her death at Auschwitz, probably on 9 August 1942, and her beatification in Cologne on 1 May 1987.
3. **The recognition of the miracle.** The AP (April 1997) reports the Vatican's announcement of 8 April 1997 that John Paul II had recognized the miracle attributed to Stein in the McCarthy case. The decree text itself was not found online.
4. **The clinical course.** The diagnosis, the transfer to Massachusetts General Hospital, the transplant preparation and Kleinman's statements are reported independently by the AP, the *Washington Post* and the National Post, the last two quoting Kleinman directly.

**Naturalistic explanations considered:**

- **Recovery from acetaminophen poisoning.** Acetaminophen overdose injures the liver, and some patients recover without a transplant even after severe injury. The question in this case is whether this patient, with the course her physician describes, could be expected to. Kleinman did not expect it, and the Vatican's medical panel judged the recovery unexplained.
- **The physician's own reading.** Kleinman told the National Post in 2010: "We know there is a hidden capacity to survive and when it comes it's for reasons we don't understand," and "There's a lot we don't know, so I wouldn't call it a miracle." He did not offer a specific natural mechanism.
- **Speed and completeness.** The reported recovery took about four days, with the liver returning to normal size and no transplant performed. The speed is what the witnesses stress.

**Caveats and remaining uncertainties:**

- **No published medical report.** Unlike some entries in this collection, the case was never written up in a medical journal, and the Vatican medical file is not public. The clinical facts come from journalists quoting the treating physician and the family.
- **The dose is reported inconsistently** (see Tensions), and no laboratory values have been published.
- **Long-term follow-up.** She was well at fourteen (1998) and at twenty-five (2010). No later medical information was found.

## Tensions

The published accounts differ on several points. They are recorded here, attributed, without choosing a winner.

- **Kleinman's own word.** The *Washington Post* (1997) quotes him: "I thought it was miraculous that she recovered." The National Post (2010) quotes him: "There's a lot we don't know, so I wouldn't call it a miracle," and "I don't believe in miracles in the Catholic sense." The first may be a description of how surprising the recovery was, the second a statement about its cause.
- **The dose.** The National Post says she took about 16 doses of Tylenol; ABC News (2010) says 19 times the lethal dose of acetaminophen.
- **The doctor's note.** *Inside the Vatican* gives "This child has made a remarkable recovery," and ABC News reports the same words from Benedicta. The *Deseret News* gives her mother's recollection: "This child has made a miraculous recovery. Report to follow."
- **The Rome testimony.** The *Washington Post* (May 1997) says Kleinman spent almost five hours before the Roman panel about nine years after the illness; the National Post (2010) says he testified for six hours in Rome in 1997.
- **Her place in the family.** The *Washington Post* calls her the 12th of 13 children (the 13th died at birth in 1986); the National Post calls her the 13th child; ABC News, the last of twelve.

## Apologetic value

- **A skeptical physician on record.** The treating doctor, Jewish by background and self-described as not believing in miracles in the Catholic sense, testified for hours at two inquiries that he had not expected the child to live. The church process depended on the testimony of a witness who did not share its conclusion.
- **A clear before and after.** Liver and kidney failure with transplant preparation, followed within days by recovery and no transplant, is a sequence reported consistently by the treating physician, the family and the church inquiries.
- **Answered prayer, read in biblical terms.** The family's prayer chain fits the pattern of intercession for the sick in [James 5:15](/codex/james-5-15/). Catholic recognition attributes the healing to Edith Stein's intercession; Protestant readers will attribute it to God answering the prayers of the family and their friends, and both agree it is God who heals.
- **Honest limits.** The medical file is unpublished, the dose is reported inconsistently, and recovery without transplant does occur in some severe acetaminophen poisonings. Deploy the case as one strand in a cumulative case. See [Argument from Miracles](/codex/argument-from-miracles/).
- **How to deploy it.** Lead with Kleinman's two statements side by side: that he did not expect her to recover, and that he still would not call it a miracle. That shows the facts were accepted by a witness with no interest in the conclusion, then let the hearer weigh the explanation.

## See also

- [Miracles](/codex/miracles/), master hub
- _schema, the vetting standard this entry follows
- [Audrey Toguchi (Damien 1999)](/codex/audrey-toguchi-damien-1999/), another American canonization miracle attested by a non-religious treating physician
- [Jake Finkbonner (Kateri Tekakwitha 2006)](/codex/jake-finkbonner-kateri-tekakwitha-2006/), another American child whose canonization miracle was documented by treating physicians
- [Candela Giarda (John Paul I 2011)](/codex/candela-giarda-john-paul-i-2011/), another child in critical care whose recovery was ratified in a canonization cause
- [Argument from Miracles](/codex/argument-from-miracles/), the argument this case supports
- [David Hume](/codex/david-hume/), whose standard for credible miracle testimony this case presses on
- [Naturalism](/codex/naturalism/), the worldview such cases press against

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:START -->

<div data-pagefind-weight="5">

## Common questions this page answers

**Q: What was the miracle for Edith Stein's canonization?**

It was the recovery of Benedicta McCarthy, a two-year-old from Brockton, Massachusetts, who swallowed a large dose of Tylenol in March 1987 and developed liver and kidney failure. Her family prayed to Edith Stein, her namesake, and she recovered within days without a transplant. The Vatican recognized the miracle in April 1997, and Stein was canonized on 11 October 1998.

**Q: Who is Benedicta McCarthy?**

Teresia Benedicta McCarthy, born in 1984, is a daughter of the Rev. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy and Mary McCarthy of Brockton, Massachusetts. She was named after Edith Stein's religious name, and her recovery from acetaminophen poisoning in 1987 was accepted as the miracle for Stein's canonization.

**Q: What did Benedicta McCarthy's doctor say about her recovery?**

Dr. Ronald Kleinman of Massachusetts General Hospital said in 1997 that he did not expect her to recover and that he "thought it was miraculous that she recovered." In 2010 he said he would not call it a miracle in the Catholic sense, and that there is a hidden capacity to survive that medicine does not understand. He testified at both the Boston and Rome inquiries.

**Q: Did Edith Stein need a miracle to be beatified?**

No. She was beatified in Cologne on 1 May 1987 as a martyr, which does not require a miracle. Canonization required one verified miracle, and the McCarthy case was the one accepted.

**Q: Can a child survive a Tylenol overdose without a liver transplant?**

Some patients with severe acetaminophen poisoning recover without a transplant, so recovery alone is not unheard of. In this case the treating physician did not expect survival, doctors had prepared for a transplant that was never performed, and the recovery came within about four days. The Vatican's medical panel judged it medically unexplained; the full medical file has not been published.

</div>

<!-- COMMON-QUESTIONS:END -->
